Journal List > Korean J Nutr > v.43(6) > 1043860

Korean J Nutr. 2010 Dec;43(6):638-652. Korean.
Published online December 31, 2010.  https://doi.org/10.4163/kjn.2010.43.6.638
© 2010 The Korean Nutrition Society
Comparison of Frequency and Amount of Dishes Reported in Semi-Quantitative Dish-based Frequency Questionnaire vs. 12-day Dietary Records
Na Yeun Song,1 Min Kyung Park,1 Hee Young Paik,1 Hyojee Joung,2 Jeong Seon Kim,3 and So Hee Park3
1Department of Food and Nutrition Seoul National University, Seoul 151-742, Korea.
2Graduate School of Public Health, Seoul National University, Seoul 110-460, Korea.
3Cancer Epidemiology Branch, National Cancer Center, Goyang 410-769, Korea.

To whom correspondence should be addressed. (Email: n251520@hotmail.com )
Received December 10, 2009; Revised November 30, 2010; Accepted December 02, 2010.

Abstract

A valid food or dish frequency questionnaire needs to be developed in Korea for accurate dietary assessment because the dietary practices of Koreans are very different from those of other countries. This study was conducted to evaluate the accuracy of the newly developed, semi-quantitative, dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ) with 12-day dietary records (12-DRs) as a gold standard. The study subjects were 115 men and 173 women aged 30-65 years old. We calibrated the frequency, portion size and daily intake of 112 dish items reported in Semi-DFQ with those in 12-DRs by Spearman rank correlation coefficients (SCCs). The consumption frequency and portion size reported in Semi-DFQ were higher than those in 12-DRs. The SCCs for the consumption frequency of various dishes ranged from -0.07 (fried seaweed) to 0.70 (instant coffee), the portion size ranged from -0.09 (cold seaweed soup) to 0.68 (soju), and the daily intake ranged from -0.07 (fried seaweed) to 0.71 (soju). The SCCs were higher for dishes consumed daily, such as steamed rice, milk, coffee and alcohol, than those of foods eaten rarely. The overall agreements between the Semi-DFQ and 12-DRs were low for categories of consumption frequency and portion size, even though some dishes showed high SCCs. The SCCs of the two methods in consumption frequency and amount were higher among the women and younger subject. The results revealed the limitation of the Semi-DFQ for evaluating the status of usual individual intake. Therefore, the Semi-DFQ can be used in addition as dietary records and 24-hour recall depending on the research aims.

Keywords: semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire; dietary records; frequency; portion size; daily intake

Figures


 Fig. 1
Flow of validation study. Semi-DFQ: Semi-quantitative Dish-based Frequency Questionnaire, 3-DR: 3-day Dietary Records.
Click for larger image


Fig. 2
Flow chart for comparison of frequency and amount of dishes reported in Semi-quantitative dish-based food frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ) vs 12-day Dietary Records (12-d DRs). 1) By spearman rank correlation coefficients between Semi-DFQ vs 12-d DRs, 2) 68% of total consumption frequency.
Click for larger image


Fig. 3
Relationships between total number of dish types for 12 days and Spearman correlation coefficients of consumption frequency on subjects (n = 288).
Click for larger image

Tables


 Table 1
Dish lists by correlation coefficients level of consumption frequency between Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ) and 12-day Dietary records
Click for larger image


Table 2
Distribution of consumption frequencies of selective dish items from 12-day Dietary records by response in Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ)
Click for larger image


Table 3
Dish lists by correlation coefficients level of portion size between Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ)and 12-day Dietary records
Click for larger image


Table 4
Comparison of portion size in Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ) with self reported amount in 12-day-Dietary records, n = 288
Click for larger image


Table 5
Dish lists by correlation coefficients level of daily intake between Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ) and 12-day Dietary records
Click for larger image


Table 6
Comparison of age and gender according to the correlation coefficients levels in reporting frequency, portion size, daily intake of dish items by Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire vs12-day Dietary records
Click for larger image


Table 7
Spearman correlation coefficients of consumption frequencies of dish group between Semi-quantitative dish-based frequency questionnaire (Semi-DFQ) and 12 day dietary records by season
Click for larger image

Notes

This research was supported by a grant from National Cancer Center in Republic of Korea (350-2008-0002).

References
1. Willet W. In: Nutritional Epidemiology. Second ed. Oxford University; 1998.
2. Vandevijvere S, De Vriese S, Huybrechts I, Moreau M, Temme E, De Henauw S, De Backer G, Kornitzer M, Leveque A, Van Oyen H. The gap between food-based dietary guidelines and usual food consumption in Belgium, 2004. Public Health Nutr 2009;12(3):423–431.
3. Dumartheray EW, Krieg MA, Cornuz J, Whittamore DR, Lovell DP, Burckhardt P, Lanham-New SA. Validation and reproducibility of a semi-quantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire for use in elderly Swiss women. J Hum Nutr Diet 2006;19(5):321–330.
4. Kim YO, Kim MK, Lee SA, Yoon YM, Sasaki S. A study testing the usefulness of a dish-based food-frequency questionnaire developed for epidemiological studies in Korea. Br J Nutr 2009;101(8):1218–1227.
5. Ovaskainen ML, Paturi M, Reinivuo H, Hannila ML, Sinkko H, Lehtisalo J, Pynnonen-Polari O, Mannisto S. Accuracy in the estimation of food servings against the portions in food photographs. Eur J Clin Nutr 2008;62(5):674–681.
6. Tokudome Y, Kuriki K, Imaeda N, Ikeda M, Nagaya T, Fujiwara N, Sato J, Goto C, Kikuchi S, Maki S, Tokudome S. Seasonal variation in consumption and plasma concentrations of fatty acids in Japanese female dietitians. Eur J Epidemiol 2003;18(10):945–953.
7. Tokudome Y, Imaeda N, Nagaya T, Ikeda M, Fujiwara N, Sato J, Kuriki K, Kikuchi S, Maki S, Tokudome S. Daily, weekly, seasonal, within- and between-individual variation in nutrient intake according to four season consecutive 7 day weighed diet records in Japanese female dietitians. J Epidemiol 2002;12(2):85–92.
8. Ahn Y, Kwon E, Shim JE, Park MK, Joo Y, Kimm K, Park C, Kim DH. Validation and reproducibility of food frequency questionnaire for Korean genome epidemiologic study. Eur J Clin Nutr 2007;61(12):1435–1441.
9. Barclay AW, Flood VM, Brand-Miller JC, Mitchell P. Validity of carbohydrate, glycaemic index and glycaemic load data obtained using a semi-quantitative food-frequency questionnaire. Public Health Nutr 2008;11(6):573–580.
10. Tokudome Y, Goto C, Imaeda N, Hasegawa T, Kato R, Hirose K, Tajima K, Tokudome S. Relative validity of a short food frequency questionnaire for assessing nutrient intake versus three-day weighed diet records in middle-aged Japanese. J Epidemiol 2005;15(4):135–145.
11. Shu XO, Yang G, Jin F, Liu D, Kushi L, Wen W, Gao YT, Zheng W. Validity and reproducibility of the food frequency questionnaire used in the Shanghai Women's Health Study. Eur J Clin Nutr 2004;58(1):17–23.
12. Villegas R, Yang G, Liu D, Xiang YB, Cai H, Zheng W, Shu XO. Validity and reproducibility of the food-frequency questionnaire used in the Shanghai men's health study. Br J Nutr 2007;97(5):993–1000.
13. Parr CL, Barikmo I, Torheim LE, Ouattara F, Kaloga A, Oshaug A. Validation of the second version of a quantitative food-frequency questionnaire for use in Western Mali. Public Health Nutr 2002;5(6):769–781.
14. Stuff JE, Goh ET, Barrera SL, Bondy ML, Forman MR. N-nitroso compounds: assessing agreement between food frequency questionnaires and 7-day food records. J Am Diet Assoc 2009;109(7):1179–1183.
15. Petkeviciene J, Simila M, Becker W, Kriaucioniene V, Valsta LM. Validity and reproducibility of the NORBAGREEN food frequency questionnaire. Eur J Clin Nutr 2009;63(1):141–149.
16. Date C, Fukui M, Yamamoto A, Wakai K, Ozeki A, Motohashi Y, Adachi C, Okamoto N, Kurosawa M, Tokudome Y, Kurisu Y, Watanabe Y, Ozasa K, Nakagawa S, Tokui N, Yoshimura T, Tamakoshi A. Reproducibility and validity of a self-administered food frequency questionnaire used in the JACC study. J Epidemiol 2005;15 Suppl 1:S9–S23.
17. Tokudome S, Imaeda N, Tokudome Y, Fujiwara N, Nagaya T, Sato J, Kuriki K, Ikeda M, Maki S. Relative validity of a semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire versus 28 day weighed diet records in Japanese female dietitians. Eur J Clin Nutr 2001;55(9):735–742.
18. Deschamps V, de Lauzon-Guillain B, Lafay L, Borys JM, Charles MA, Romon M. Reproducibility and relative validity of a food-frequency questionnaire among French adults and adolescents. Eur J Clin Nutr 2009;63(2):282–291.
19. Kim YO. Differences in Nutrient Intakes Analysed by Using Food Frequency and Recall Method. J Korean Soc Food Sci Nutr 1995;24(6):887–891.
20. Paik HY, Choi JS, Ahn YJ, Moon HK. Development and Validation of Food Frequency Questionnaire for Dietary Assessment of Korean Adults in Rural Area. Korean J Nutr 1995;28(9):914–922.
21. Lee HJ, Kim JH, Kim CI, Chang KJ. Development and Validation of a Computerized Semi-Quantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire Program for Evaluating the Nutritional Status of the Korean Elderly. Korean J Community Nutr 2002;7(2):277–285.
22. Kim MY, Nam CM, Yoon JY, Shim JS, Oh KW. The Development and Evaluation of a Simple Semi-Quantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire Using the Contribution of Specific Foods to Absolute Intake and Between-Person Variation of Nutrition Consumption. Korean J Nutr 2002;35(2):250–262.
23. Oh SY, Hong MH. Development of a Simple Food Frequency Questionnaire Using the Contribution of Specific Foods to Absolute Intake and Between-Person Variation of Nutrient Consumption for the Korean Elderly. Korean J Nutr 2000;33(4):429–437.
24. Lee SY, Paik HY. Comparative assessment of nutrient intake and quality obtained by food frequency questionnaire and 24-hour recall method in Korean adults living in rural area. J Korean Home Econ Assoc 1998;36(1):143–155.
25. Won SH, Kim WY. Development and Validation of a SemiQuantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire to Evaluate Nutritional Status of the Korean Elderly. Korean J Nutr 2000;33(3):314–323.
26. Kim WY, Yang EJ. A Study on Development and Validation of Food Frequency Questionnaire for Koreans. Korean J Nutr 1998;31(2):220–230.
27. Anh YJ, Paik HY, Lee HK, Park YS. Comparison of Food Intakes between Newly Diagnosed Diabetics and Nondiabetics by Food Frequency Questionnaire in Adults Living in Rural Area of Korea. J Korean Soc Food Sci Nutr 1998;27(1):182–190.
28. Oh SY, Hong MH. Repeatability of a Semi-quantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire of the Korean Elderly. Korean J Nutr 1998;31(7):1183–1191.
29. Shim JS, Oh KW, Kim MY, Sohn CY. A Study on Validity of a Semi-Quantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire for Korean Adults. Korean J Community Nutr 2002;7(4):484–494.
30. Neuhouser ML, Patterson RE, Thornquist MD, Omenn GS, King IB, Goodman GE. Fruits and vegetables are associated with lower lung cancer risk only in the placebo arm of the beta-carotene and retinol efficacy trial (CARET). Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev 2003;12(4):350–358.
31. Ministry for Health, Welfare and Family Affairs. Development and validation of dish-based semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire for diet and cancer research. 2009. pp. 0720660.
32. Jung HJ, Moon SJ, Lee LH, Yu CH, Paik HY. Evaluation of Elementary School Lunch Menus Based on Maintenance of the Traditional Dietary Pattern. Korean J Nutr 2000;33(2):216–229.
33. Marks GC, Hughes MC, van der Pols JC. Relative validity of food intake estimates using a food frequency questionnaire is associated with sex, age, and other personal characteristics. J Nutr 2006;136(2):459–465.
34. Lee GS, Yi MS, Joung HJ. Response Experiences with a Semi-Quantitative Food Frequency Questionnaire: A Qualitative Study using Cognitive Interview. Korean J Nutr 2007;40(6):566–575.
35. Thompson FE, Subar AF, Brown CC, Smith AF, Sharbaugh CO, Jobe JB, Mittl B, Gibson JT, Ziegler RG. Cognitive research enhances accuracy of food frequency questionnaire reports: results of an experimental validation study. J Am Diet Assoc 2002;102(2):212–225.
36. Paalanen L, Mannisto S, Virtanen MJ, Knekt P, Rasanen L, Montonen J, Pietinen P. Validity of a food frequency questionnaire varied by age and body mass index. J Clin Epidemiol 2006;59(9):994–1001.
37. Hansson LM, Galanti MR, Bergstrom R. Factors affecting reproducibility of dietary reports using food frequency questionnaires. Eur J Clin Nutr 2000;54(8):658–664.
38. Bernstein MA, Tucker KL, Ryan ND, O'Neill EF, Clements KM, Nelson ME, Evans WJ, Fiatarone Singh MA. Higher dietary variety is associated with better nutritional status in frail elderly people. J Am Diet Assoc 2002;102(8):1096–1104.
TOOLS
Similar articles

Comparison Between Semi-Quantitative Frequency Methods and 7-day Dietary Records Methods in Food and Nutrition Intake Status For Hemodialysis Patients

Relative validities of 3-day food records and the food frequency questionnaire

Development and relative validity of semi-quantitative food frequency questionnaire for Korean adults

Development of a Food Frequency Questionnaire for the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey: Data from the Fourth Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES IV)

Development of a food frequency questionnaire for dietary intake of preschool children