Isolated A1 Pulley Rupture of Left Fourth Finger in Kendo Players: Two Case Reports

Jin Hyung Lee; Hyoung Seop Kim; Seung Ho Joo

doi:10.5535/arm.2015.39.5.838

Abstract

Annular pulley injury of fingers is usually observed in rock climbers who support their entire body weight with flexed fingers during climbing. But these lesions can also follow trivial trauma, such as lifting heavy objects with the fingertips, or during sports and recreational activities. The A2 and A4 pulleys are most usually involved and reported most frequently. However, traumatic A1 pulley rupture has not been reported yet, to the best of our knowledge. Kendo is a very vigorous martial art with frequent physical contact. Therefore, we reported two cases of repetitive microtraumatic left fourth finger A1 pulley rupture in Kendo players with results from physical examination and imaging studies, such as ultrasonography and magnetic resonance imaging, together with related literature.

INTRODUCTION

A series of retinacular structures around the synovial tendon sheath of the fingers thicken the sheath at 5 specific points, forming the annular pulley system (pulleys A1-A5); while additional fibers that crisscross between the annular pulleys create the cruciate pulley system (pulleys C1-C3). These pulleys combine to prevent excursion of the flexor tendons from the metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joints during finger flexion [1]. Therefore, annular pulley injuries lower mechanical efficiency and reduce digital performance.

Annular pulley ruptures may occur during powerful flexion of fingers with the metacarpophalangeal joint in extension and proximal interphalangeal joint in flexion. Pulley ruptures usually involve long fingers, particularly the A2 pulley of the fourth finger of the non-dominant hand [2]. Since these injuries are typically detected in rock climbers, they are commonly referred to as climber's finger [3]. In general, A2 and A4 pulleys are most commonly involved, especially the A2 pulley tear. The pathomechanics of closed annular pulley rupture is initial partial tear of the distal end of A2 pulley followed by progression to complete rupture and involvement of the A3 and A4 pulleys. However, the A1 pulley is rarely involved [2].

Isolated A1 pulley rupture has not been reported yet. Thus, we reported two cases of Kendo players with isolated A1 pulley rupture of the left fourth finger, together with related literature.

CASE REPORTS

Case 1

A 24-year-old national Kendo athlete visited the outpatient Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation for left fourth and fifth finger pain ongoing for a year. The patient was diagnosed with 'trigger finger' at a local orthopedic clinic and other oriental traditional medicine clinics. The patient was treated with local injection and acupuncture several times without improvement of symptoms.

The patient received Kendo training for 4 hours a day since elementary school and used protective gloves most of the time. The patient was usually pain free, but despite the absence of definite trauma history, there was aggravation of pain at the left fourth and fifth metacarpal bone area during training.

There was no difference between both hands at resting state, but the left fourth finger tendon protruded from the palm when fingers were flexed against resistant force (Fig. 1). On manual muscle test examination, there was mild left side weakness of Medical Research Council (MRC) good grade of the fourth and fifth finger flexors, but no abnormality when they were extended or abducted.

On sensory nerve testing no abnormality on pinprick, touch and vibration stimulation was observed. Electromyography evaluation to rule out possible ulnar nerve injury showed results within normal limits. The patient was referred to a radiologist to evaluate for finger flexor tendon lesions.

A radiologist with at least 3 years of musculoskeletal ultrasonographic experience performed the ultrasonographic examinations using a 5-12 MHz iU22 (Philips Medical System, Bothell, WA, USA) linear array transducer. Ultrasonographic evaluation was performed on the extended fingers in resting position from the head of the metacarpal bones to the distal phalanges on supine position. Active forced flexion against resistance was provided by the radiologist with his fingertips to ensure the highest tendon detachment.

The A1 pulley of the left fourth finger was not observed and the flexor tendon was detached from the volar plate in the longitudinal scan on ultrasonography (Fig. 2). Furthermore, the difference of tendon detachment between rest and forced finger flexion was unclear. However, the tendon was detached about 1.2 mm, as compared to the contralateral side. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed to confirm the lesion at the patient's finger, which showed signal changes at the flexor tendon that was considered as tendinosis on sagittal scan view. Ultimately, the left fourth flexor tendon was detached from the metacarpal head on axial scan (Fig. 3).

Case 2

A 53-year-old amateur Kendo athlete visited the outpatient Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation complaining of left fourth metacarpophalangeal joint pain. He had received Kendo training for 20 years and used protective gloves most of the time. Like the above case, the patient did not feel pain during rest, but pain was present at the left fourth and fifth metacarpal area during Kendo training. Similarly, the left fourth finger tendon protruded clearly from the palm when counter force was applied to both fourth fingers.

A physiatrist with 5 years of musculoskeletal ultrasonographic experience performed the ultrasonographic examinations using a 5-12 MHz Voluson i (GE Healthcare, London, UK) linear array transducer with the same method as in the first case.

Detachment of the flexor tendon from the volar plate was not clear on longitudinal scanning, but the hypoechoic A1 pulley was not observed in longitudinal and transverse views (Fig. 4). Though MRI was not performed due to refusal by the patient, we were able to diagnose isolated A1 pulley rupture with thorough history taking and ultrasonographic evaluation.

DISCUSSION

Kendo, the Japanese sword art, is a popular martial art in Korea and is a vigorous exercise with frequent physical contact but low injury risk with proper use of safety equipment [4].

When a Kendo player grasps a bamboo sword, the right hand is placed in front of the left hand. A player uses the right hand as a fulcrum point and the left hand as the main source of force. Thus, a Kendo player grasps the bamboo sword more forcefully with the left hand than the right hand, and the distal end of the bamboo sword is placed in the mid palm of the left hand for smooth changes in direction during swinging of the sword. The two patients in our case also followed this method. Since protective gloves are worn at all times, wrist and finger injuries have been rarely reported during Kendo sparring. Injuries in Kendo occur more commonly at the foot, ankle, heel, glenohumeral joint, shoulder joint and knee joint, as compared to other martial arts [4 5].

Pulley system injuries mainly involve the A2 to A4, while A1 and A5 pulley injuries are rarely reported [2 6]. However, the cause of isolated A1 pulley rupture in Kendo players is considered to be the grasping method of the bamboo sword (Fig. 5). When sparring with an opponent, most of the impact force is concentrated at the left fourth metacarpophalangeal joint because the distal end of bamboo sword is located around the fourth metacarpophalangeal joint, and such chronic microtrauma is thought to cause A1 pulley rupture.

When A2 pulley ruptures occur, pain aggravates with finger flexion, and maximal volar displacement occurs over the proximal phalanx [6]. However in our cases, physical examination showed that volar displacement occurred over the palm and not over the proximal phalanx when counter force was applied on the left fourth fingertip.

A dynamic study with active forced flexion of an involved finger is usually required to detect A2 pulley injuries with ultrasonography. With the probe placed on the affected finger with active forced flexion against resistance, the presence of pathological increment of distance between the flexor tendon and phalanx (tendon-phalanx distance) in longitudinal plane is considered as pulley injuries [6 7]. Klauser et al. [6] reported that the tendon-phalanx distance was greater with active forced flexion than at rest; in addition, the tendon-phalanx distance of complete injury was greater than that of incomplete injury with active forced flexion. They also noted that the observed distance increased with the number of pulleys involved. Based on their study and previous reports, a distance of ≥1.0 mm is indicative of pulley system injury and <3.0 mm with forced flexion is considered a sign of incomplete rupture of the A2 pulley.

However, in our cases, scanning with active forced flexion did not show considerable increment of tendon-phalanx distance, as compared with scanning on rest. This difference was possibly due to the anatomical site of the pulley i.e., the A2 pulley is located at the mid-shaft of proximal phalanx between the metacarpophalangeal joint and the proximal interphalangeal joint, causing easy displacement of the specific finger flexor tendon from the phalanx on injury. However, since the A1 pulley is located just above the metacarpophalangeal joint, the probe must be placed in the middle of the joint to detect A1 pulley injuries. Thus, in A1 pulley injuries, ultrasonographic examination with active forced flexion may not show a difference in increment of tendon-phalanx distance compared with the ultrasonographic examination at rest, as in A2 pulley injuries.

Transverse views in ultrasonography did not provide any additional significant information in the evaluation of A2 pulley injury [6]. However, on transverse view in the second case, hypoechoic rims that represent the left fourth A1 pulley were not observed and fourth finger flexor tendon was closer to the subcutaneous tissue, as compared to its neighboring or contralateral tendon. It can also be explained by anatomical position. As the A1 pulley is located at the mid palm area, transverse view evaluations with ultrasonography reveals A1 pulley injuries more clearly than other pulley injuries. Thus the transverse view study is as important as the longitudinal view study in detecting A1 pulley injuries.

MR images also provide additional assessment of annular pulley injuries [7]. Sagittal and axial MR images directly depict tears as a defect of the pulley. However, MR imaging is more time-consuming, more costly and less universally available, as compared with ultrasonography [8]. Furthermore, MR imaging, does not enable real-time evaluations such as active forced flexion. For detection of pulley injuries, ultrasonography demonstrated high accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value, as compared to MR imaging. In the second case, we were able to diagnose A1 pulley injury with careful physical examination and ultrasonography alone, without taking MR images.

In conclusion, two cases of isolated A1 pulley rupture were diagnosed in Kendo players. The probable cause of the injury was the grasping method in which the left hand grasps the cylindrical handle firmly and the distal tip of bamboo sword is located around the mid left fourth metacarpal bone. This causes the impact force to be transferred to the A1 pulley when making swinging, slicing and stabbing motions with the sword during sparring. These were the first diagnosed cases of isolated A1 pulley rupture in Kendo players based on history and physical examination, ultrasonography and MR images.