PDF
ePub
Citation
Print
INTRODUCTION
Down syndrome (DS, Trisomy 21) is a well-recognized genetic condition with various associated medical issues, most notably congenital heart disease (CHD).1) An estimated 50% of patients with DS have CHD, and an atrial septal defect (ASD) has been reported in 8% of patients with DS.2) Patients with DS have a high risk of developing pulmonary hypertension (PH) compared to genetically normal individuals.3) The high risk of PH among patients with DS is related to greater incidence of airway obstruction, tracheobronchomalacia, hypoplastic lung, and gastroesophageal reflux disease.1)4) PH has been reported in 9% to 35% of patients with a secundum ASD, regardless of whether it is open or closed.5)6) PH is reversible in some patients when ASD closure is performed during early childhood. However, in some patients, PH is irreversible, and their outcomes following ASD closure are often poorer than in those who do not undergo closure.7) As such, ASD closure in patients with DS and severe PH is controversial due to concerns regarding PH exacerbation. The aim of this study was to determine the clinical outcome and reversibility of severe PH after surgical closure of hemodynamically significant ASD in children with DS.
METHODS
We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of patients with DS who underwent surgical ASD patch closure at our hospital from January 2000 to December 2016. Patients with complex CHD with ASD were excluded from the study. The degree of PH was diagnosed by transthoracic echocardiography and clinical symptoms. The degree of PH was divided into mild, moderate, and severe, according to tricuspid regurgitation peak velocity and configuration of the interventricular septum. We classified PH as mild if the systolic pulmonary artery pressure (sPAP) was below 50% of the systemic systolic pressure, moderate if the sPAP was 50%-100% of the systemic systolic pressure, and severe if the sPAP was greater than 100% of the systemic systolic pressure. The sPAP can be estimated from the tricuspid regurgitation jet flow and is calculated using the modified Bernoulli equation [systolic pulmonary artery pressure = 4 × (tricuspid regurgitation peak jet velocity)2 + right atrial pressure].8)9) The systolic pulmonary arterial pressure was also graded according to configuration of the interventricular septum. Partial flattening of the interventricular septum (round interventricular septum at end-systole) indicates a right ventricular (RV) systolic pressure below 50% of the systemic systolic pressure. Flattening of the interventricular septum at end-systole indicates that the RV pressure is 50%-100% of the systemic systolic pressure. A squeezed left ventricle at end-systole indicates that the RV pressure is greater than 100% of the systemic systolic pressure.8)
We also reviewed the patients' surgical records and laboratory findings to determine the severity of PH and perioperative change in clinical data. Furthermore, we reviewed the data on cardiac catheterization to determine the severity and reversibility of PH before ASD closure. We also serially reviewed patients' echocardiographic data to evaluate for PH regression after ASD closure.
This study was approved by the institutional review board of our hospital, and informed consent was waived given the retrospective nature of this study.
RESULTS
A total of 15 patients underwent surgery for ASD (Table 1). Nine patients (60%) were diagnosed with PH by echocardiography before ASD patch closure. Five patients (33%) had mild, one patient (7%) had moderate, and three patients (20%) had severe PH (Figure 1). Among them, three patients (20%) were taking multiple selective pulmonary vasodilators (bosentan, sildenafil) for severe PH before ASD closure. The mean age at surgical ASD patch closure was 17.3 months (range: 2 months to 11 years), and the mean ASD defect diameter was 10.2 mm (range: 4.9-15.8 mm). Six patients (40%) did not have PH before ASD closure.
Table 1
Patient demographics and treatment outcomes
Figure 1
Pulmonary hypertension (PH) severity before surgical atrial septal defect repair. Three of 15 patients (20%) had severe PH before surgery.
One patient (female, one-year-old) underwent diagnostic cardiac catheterization with an acute pulmonary vasoreactivity test (AVT) before ASD closure. The patient's mean pulmonary arterial pressure was 66 mmHg and pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR) was 10.7 Wood units/m2. Following O2 inhalation (10 L/min via mask), the mean pulmonary arterial pressure dropped to 44 mmHg, and the PVR decreased to 2.17 Wood units/m2. Therefore, we decided to perform surgical ASD closure with confidence.
Three patients (20%) who were taking selective pulmonary vasodilators for severe PH before ASD closure underwent ASD patch closure at ages 7, 12, and 25 months, respectively (Table 2). Table 3 shows echocardiographic changes in patients with severe PH after ASD closure. Two patients continued medication for an additional 13 and 21 months after surgery, and one patient remained on medication for 52 months after ASD closure. PH did not recur following discontinuation of selective pulmonary vasodilators in two patients. One female patient showed improved PH, from severe to mild, on echocardiography three months after ASD closure. However, PH recurred six months after ASD closure, and the patient was hospitalized at a different institution several times due to pneumonia and dyspnea over the course of two years. Two years following ASD closure, the patient's respiratory symptoms gradually improved, and the patient had not been hospitalized in the previous six months. The patient had been taking pulmonary vasodilators (bosentan and sildenafil) due to moderate PH diagnosed by echocardiography. However, all patients with severe PH improved after ASD closure. Six patients who had PH before ASD closure and were not taking selective pulmonary vasodilators showed improvement within one week of ASD closure. The remaining six patients who did not have PH prior to ASD closure did not develop PH after ASD closure.
Table 2
Clinical outcomes of three patients with severe PH before ASD closure
Table 3
Echocardiographic changes in patients with severe pulmonary hypertension
Ten of the 15 patients in this study have been followed up at our hospital and none have died. The remaining five patients were lost to follow-up. Four of them were alive and without symptoms of heart disease at their most recent visit, although one patient had moderate PH that seemed to be improving gradually after ASD closure as described above. The mean survival years after ASD closure was 6.22 ± 3.74 years.
DISCUSSION
All patients with DS included in this study showed PH regression after ASD closure, including three patients who had severe PH before ASD closure, when closure was accompanied by therapy with multiple selective pulmonary vasodilators. PH can progress very rapidly and be more severe in patients with DS due to a number of contributing factors that affect disease progression.4)10)11) Although CHD, including ASD, can influence the progression of PH, it is also vital to search for other common causes of PH in DS patients, such as upper airway obstruction, tracheobronchomalacia, hypoplastic lung, gastro-esophageal reflux, abnormal pulmonary vasculature growth, and recurrent pulmonary infection, and to manage these conditions appropriately.4)11)
The majority of ASD patients is asymptomatic, with diverse symptoms manifesting as the patient gets older.12)13) Continuous exposure of the pulmonary vasculature to increased blood flow in patients with ASD may cause histological changes in the intima and media of the pulmonary arteries and arterioles, with resultant luminal narrowing and subsequent aggravation of PH.14) Even when the patient is asymptomatic, severe complications, such as RV failure, atrial arrhythmias, paradoxical embolization, cerebral abscess formation, PH, and even Eisenmenger syndrome, can occur.12)
An AVT can help assess whether or not patients with PH and CHD are operative candidates. A baseline PVR index < 6 Wood units/m2 and a PVR/SVR (systemic vascular resistance) < 0.3 have been used as indicators of favorable prognosis after repair, with no need for vasoreactivity testing.15) AVT is required if the baseline PVR is between 6 and 9 Wood units/m2 and PVR/SVR is between 0.3 and 0.5.15) We can predict a favorable outcome after ASD closure when the final PVR index is < 6 Wood units/m2 and the final PVR/SVR is < 0.3 or there is a greater than 20% decrease in the PVR index after AVT.16)17)Although these are currently the best measures of assessing candidacy for surgical intervention, there is still no consensus as to whether the vasoreactivity test is sufficiently accurate to identify patients who will have a favorable outcome after surgery.17)
The current life expectancy for patients with PH and DS is into the fourth or fifth decade of life, and it is well known that comorbidities can have a significant effect on quality of life.4) PH can be prevented if the ASD is closed early, but careful consideration of operative intervention is necessary in patients with a left-to-right shunt through the defect.18)19)
A novel treatment and repair approach for PH associated with CHD has recently been introduced. This approach involves treating a patient previously considered to have irreversible, inoperable CHD with targeted pulmonary vasodilator therapy to reduce their PH, followed by surgery to repair the cardiac defect.20) In the past, severe PH associated with a septal defect has been considered inoperable, as patients are perceived to have irreversible obstructive pulmonary vascular disease that puts them at high operative risk with a low possibility of benefit from the operation.20)
Nevertheless, despite the established long-term pulmonary vascular disease with evidence of significant vascular remodeling/obstruction, Eisenmenger patients often show a good response to advanced selective pulmonary vasodilator therapy.21) It has been established that almost one-third of Eisenmenger patients have some degree of pulmonary vasoreactivity despite obstructive PH.22)
Some cases with severe PH and ASD have shown improvement with the treatment and repair technique.20) Schwerzmann et al.23) described a 38-year-old woman with a large ASD and significant PAH (mean pulmonary arterial pressure 53 mmHg and PVR 8 Wood units/m2) who underwent percutaneous ASD closure after one year of therapy with intravenous prostacyclin. After ASD closure, bosentan therapy was continued, and the pulmonary arterial pressure was markedly reduced. Imanaka et al.24) described a 51-year-old patient with an ASD and severe PAH. After ASD closure, she experienced recurrent pulmonary hypertensive crises and was treated with nitric oxide. Two years later, her systolic pulmonary arterial pressure had decreased from 96 to 52 mmHg and PVR from 14 to 10 Wood units/m2.
However, all of these patients showed a significant response with advanced selective pulmonary vasodilator therapy; there is limited data regarding outcomes of successful ASD repair in patients who have no response to advanced therapy. Further studies are required to fully elucidate the long-term effects and risks of this approach.11)
Our study has some limitations. First, the number of study participants was small, with few patients who had both DS and PH with an ASD. Further multicenter studies with large cohorts are required to support the findings of this study. Secondly, although the gold standard for diagnosing PH is cardiac catheterization, this was only performed in one patient; PH in other patients was diagnosed based on echocardiography and clinical symptoms.
In conclusion, there were no patients with PH progression after ASD closure, including three patients who had severe PH before ASD closure. Our findings suggest that children with DS and severe PH with a large ASD may undergo surgery for ASD closure during early childhood without exacerbation of PH by using multiple selective pulmonary vasodilators.
XML Download