Journal List > J Korean Radiol Soc > v.42(1) > 1068798

Lee, Park, Chung, Youn, Lee, Ji, and Lee: Absent Bow-Tie Sign in Knee MRI

Abstract

PURPOSE: 'Absent bow-tie sign'is interpreted as positive when a bow-tie-shaped body segment is seen on only one or no slice of 4- or 5-mm thick sagittal images, and is a well known as a useful sign in diagnosing bucket-handle meniscal tears. In practice, however, we have found that this sign was also positive in certain cases other than bucket-handle tears. We have assumed that if the normal range of meniscal body width, as determined among Westerners, is transferred to the Korean population without verification and modification this might lead to misdiagnosis. The purpose of this study, therefore, is to examine the reliability of the 'absent bow-tie sign'. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Among 454 cases in which knee MRI had been performed, we retrospectively evaluated 862 menisci, the total remaining after cases of discoid meniscus or those involving previous meniscectomy had been excluded. Among the 862 menisci, 614 were normal, 97 showed degeneration, 43 showed buck-et-handle tearing, and 108 showed tears other than bucket-handle tear. In all cases, proton-denwity and T2-weighted images were obtained in both sagittal and coronal planes, with 3mm section thickness and 1mm gap. We recorded the number of sagittal images in which the body segment of each meniscus had a bow-tie appear-ance, and measured the width of each meniscal body, as seen on midcoronal images. RESULTS: In all cases but one of bucket-handle tears (97.7%), the bow-tie sign was absent, as it was in 73.2% ofnon-bucket-handle tears, 35.0% of degenerated menisci and 27.5% of normal menisci. Among the non-tear group, 56.4% of menisci in the female group and 27.1% in the male group had bodies less than 9mm wide. CONCLUSION: In the diagnosis of bucket-handle tears, the 'absent bow-tie sign'is a very sensitive indicator. It is nonspecific, however, and merely suggests some significant deficiency in the meniscus body or small menis-ci,so can be positive in other cases. Thus the interpreter should be aware of the characteristics of this sign especially when used to interpret MRI of the knee of a female Korean patient.

TOOLS
Similar articles