Abstract
Figures and Tables
Table 1
Author (year, country) | Study type | Population (N) | Age (years, mean ± S.D) | Cancer type (stage) | Clinical outcomes (mean ± S.D, N [%]) | Complications | Result (experimental vs. control group [N (%)]) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Preoperative | |||||||
Fujitani et al. (2012) Japan [13] | RCT (Feb. 2006-Dec. 2009) |
127/115 (ID/CT) ID (Impact® added to normal diet for 5 days before surgery) |
ID (64, median) (range: 26-78) CT (65, median) (range: 30-79 |
Gastric adeno-carcinoma (T1-T4) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - ID (18 [9-85]) - CT (17 [10-88]) - p = 0.395 2) Re-operation - ID (0 [0]) - CT (0 [0]) 3) Mortality - ID (0 [0]) - CT (0 [0]) |
1) Any complication - abdominal abscess - pancreatic fistula - anastomotic leakage - wound infection or dehiscence - drain infection - pneumonia - venous catheter infection - pleural effusion - postoperative bleeding - Ileus 2) SIRS |
1) 37 (30.8)/29 (26.1); p = 0.468 - 11 (9.2)/7 (6.3); p = 0.469 - 8 (6.7)/7 (6.3); p = 1.000 - 3 (2.5)/3 (2.7); p = 1.000 - 13 (10.8)/8 (7.2); p = 0.369 - 3 (2.5)/1 (0.9); p = 0.623 - 5 (4.2)/0 (0); p = 0.061 - 2 (1.7)/1 (0.9); p = 1.000 - 1 (0.8)/1 (0.9); p = 1.000 - 3 (2.5)/0 (0); p = 0.248 - 2 (1.7)/1 (0.9); p = 1.000 2) 46 (38.3)/34 (30.6); p = 0.268 |
Okamoto et al. (2009) Japan [14] | RCT (Apr. 2005-July. 2007) |
30/30 (ID/CT) ID (formulas supplemented with arginine, RNA, & ω-3 fatty acids for 7 days before surgery) |
ID (66.9 ± 11.5) CT (70.9 ± 13.2) |
Gastric carcinoma (I-IV) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - ID (23.8 ± 16.6) - CT (25 ± 10.6) - p = 0.22 |
1) Infectious complications - infection of incisional wound/effusion - respiratory tract infection - abdominal cavity empyema/effusion - catheter infection 2) Non-infectious complications - cardiac dysfunction - intestinal obstruction - edematous of anastomosis - bleeding 3) SIRS (days) |
1) 2 (7)/8 (28); p = 0.039 - 1 (3)/2 (7) - 1 (3)/2 (7) - 0/3 (10) - 0/1 (3) 2) 4 (13)/4 (13); p = 1.000 - 0/1 (3) - 1 (3)/0 - 2 (7)/3 (10) - 1 (3)/0 3) 0.77 (± 0.90)/1.34 (± 1.45); p = 0.04 |
Postoperative | |||||||
Hirao et al. (2005) Japan [15] | RCT (Nov. 1999-Nov. 2002) | 53/50 (EOF/CR) |
EOF (62 ± 10) (range: 35-82) CR (61 ± 13) (range: 29-85) |
Gastric carcinoma (Ia, Ib) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EOF (18.5 ± 5.9) - CR (21.7 ± 8.8) - p = 0.02 2) Weight loss (kg) - EOF (-3.7 ± 1.6) - CR (-4.4 ± 2.2) - p = 0.07 |
1) Vomiting and postprandial pain 2) Fever 3) Anastomotic leakage 4) Intra-abdominal abscess 5) Ileus 6) Intra-abdominal bleeding 7) Pneumonia 8) Lymphorrhea 9) Anorexia 10) Constipation |
1) 8 (15)/8 (16); ns 2) 7 (13)/4 (8); ns 3) 0/1; ns 4) 1/1; ns 5) 0/1 (2); ns 6) 1 (2)/0; ns 7) 0/1 (2); ns 8) 1/0; ns 9) 1/0; ns 10) 0/1 (2); ns |
Postoperative | |||||||
Hong et al. (2014) China [16] | RCT (Oct. 2011-Mar. 2013) | 40/44 (EOF/LOF) |
EOF (55.4 ± 11.2) LOF (52.1 ± 10.3) |
pTNM (I-IV) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EOF (6.28 ± 1.26) - LOF (7.69 ± 1.53) - p = 0.048 2) Time until flatus (days) - EOF (2.06 ± 1.47) - LOF (3.56 ± 1.04) - p = 0.044 3) Re-operation - EOF (0 [0]) - LOF (1 [2.27]) - p =0.337 |
1) Anastomotic leak 2) Fever 3) Pulmonary infection 4) Wound infection 5) Wound bleeding 6) Wound dehiscence |
1) 0/0 2) 1 (2.50)/1 (2.27); p = 0.946 3) 0 (0)/1 (2.27); p = 0.337 4) 1 (2.50)/1 (2.27); p = 0.946 5) 0/0 6) 0/0 |
Hur et al. (2009) Korea [17] | Pilot (Sep. 2007-Jan. 2008) | 35/31 (EOF/LOF) | EOF (55.2 ± 15.4) (range: 21-85) | Gastric adeno-carcinoma (AJCC: I-IV) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EOF (8.03 ± 1.43) - LOF (9.97 ± 2.07) - p < 0.001 2) Time until flatus (days) - EOF (1.96 ± 0.58) - LOF (2.97 ± 0.66) - p < 0.001 |
1) Morbidity - infective complication - GI morbidity - other morbidity |
1) 8 (22.9)/10 (32.3); p = 0.392 - 4 (11.4)/6 (19.4); p = 0.496 - 2 (5.7)/3 (9.7); p = 0.659 - 2 (5.7)/1 (3.8); p = 1.000 |
Hur et al. (2011) Korea [18] | RCT (Jul. 2008-Feb. 2009) | 28/26 (EOF/LOF) | 20-75 | Gastric adeno-carcinoma |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EOF (7.2 ± 1.7) - LOF (8.5 ± 2.9) - p = 0.044 2) Time until flatus (days) - EOF (1.9 ± 1.2) - LOF (2.9 ± 0.8) - p = 0.036 3) Re-operation - EOF (0 [0]) - LOF (2 [8]) - p = 0.227 4) Re-admission - EOF (1 [4]) - LOF (3 [12]) - p = 0.047 |
1) Morbidity | 1) 7 (25)/8 (31); p = 0.636 |
Postoperative | |||||||
Jeong et al. (2014) Korea [19] | Case-control (Sep. 2010-Mar. 2011) | 74/96 (EOF/LOF) |
EOF (59.9 ± 11.6) LOF (61.2 ± 11.9) |
EGC/AGC (AJCC: T1a, T1b, T2, T3, T4a) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EOF (7.4 ± 1.9) - LOF (8.9 ± 4.0) - p = 0.004 2) Time until flatus (days) - EOF (2.7 ± 1.3) - LOF (2.6 ± 1.0) - p = 0.524 3) Re-operation - EOF (1 [1.4]) - LOF (2 [2.1]) - p = 0.820 4) Morbidity - EOF (9 [12.2]) - LOF (12 [12.5]) - p = 0.947 5) Mortality - EOF (0 [0]) - LOF (0 [0]) |
1) Morbidity 2) Local complications 3) Systemic complications |
1) 9 (12.2)/12 (12.5); p = 0.947 2) 8 (10.8)/10 (10.4); p = 0.933 3) 2 (2.7)/3 (3.1); p = 0.767 |
Kamei et al. (2005) Japan [21] | RCT (Jan. 2001-Dec. 2002) | 27/21 (OEN/TPN) |
OEN (62 ± 10) TPN (65 ± 11) |
Gastric carcinoma (tumor site: lower, middle, upper, entire, remnant) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - OEN (23.1 ± 7.2) - TPN (27.6 ± 4.7) - p = 0.0345 |
1) Esophagojejunal leak 2) Leakage of duodenal stump 3) Ileus 4) Pancreatitis 5) Wound infection 6) Deep venous thrombosis 7) Abdominal cramps 8) Diarrhea 9) Nausea |
1) 0/2 (9.5); p = 0.105 2) 1 (3.7)/0; p = 0.383 3) 1 (3.7)/1 (4.7); p = 0.859 4) 1 (3.7)/0; p = 0.383 5) 2 (7.4)/1 (4.7); p = 0.714 6) 0/1 (4.7); p = 0.261 7) 2 (7.4)/1 (4.7); p = 0.714 8) 7 (25.9)/4 (19.0); p = 0.583 9) 4 (14.8)/2 (9.5); p = 0.591 |
Postoperative | |||||||
Sierzega et al. (2015) Poland [20] | RCT (2006-2012) | 185/168 (EOF/LOF) |
EOF (63, median) LOF (64, median) (range: 26-84) |
AJCC (T1-T4) |
1) Hospital stay (days, median) - EOF [7] - LOF [8] - p < 0.001 2) Re-operation - EOF [11] - LOF [11] - p = 0.815 3) Mortality - EOF [5] - LOF [6] - p = 0.639 |
1) Surgical complications - wound infection - abdominal fluid collection - anastomotic leakage - pancreatic fistula - abscess - peritonitis - ileus - abdominal bleeding - duodenal stump leakage - other 2) General complications - pneumonia - respiratory failure - heart failure - renal failure - urinary tract infection - sepsis - liver failure - other |
1) 27 (15)/40 (24); p = 0.027 - 12/12; p = 0.806 - 8/20; p = 0.008 - 7/2; p = 0.122 - 6/11; p = 0.147 - 3/8; p = 0.089 - 3/1; p = 0.362 - 3/1; p = 0.362 - 1/1; p = 0.945 - 1/4; p = 0.143 - 3/4; p = 0.609 2) 15 (8)/38 (23); p < 0.001 - 9/24; p = 0.003 - 6/17; p = 0.009 - 6/11; p = 0.147 - 2/4; p = 0.345 - 1/4; p = 0.143 - 1/5; p = 0.077 - 0/2; p = 0.136 - 3/4; p = 0.609 |
RCT: randomized controlled trial, ID: immunonutrition diet, CR: conventional fixed regimen, EOF: early oral feeding, LOF: late oral feeding, RNA: ribonucleic acid, SIRS: systematic inflammatory response syndrome, OEN: oral enternal nutrition, TPN: total parental nutrition, pTNM: pathological tumor-node-metastasis, EGC: early gastric cancer, AGC: advanced gastric cancer, AJCC: American Joint Committee on Cancer Classification, ns: not significant, CT: control group, GI: Gastrointestinal.
Table 2
Author (year, country) | Study type | Population (N) | Age (years, mean ± S.D) | Cancer type (stage) | Clinical outcomes (mean ± S.D, N [%]) | Complications | Result (experimental vs. control group [N (%)]) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Early enternal nutrition (EEN) vs. Parental nutrition (PN) & Traditional perioperative treatment (TP) | |||||||
Kim et al. (2012) Korea [23] | RCT (Mar. 2006-July. 2007) | 17/16 (EEN/TPN) |
EEN (60) TPN (64.5) [median] |
AGC |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EN [12] - TPN [13] - p = 0.289 |
1) Infectious complication 2) Nausea & vomiting 3) Abdominal distension |
1) 0/0 2) 2 (11.7)/0; p = 0.485 3) 1 (5.9)/0; p = 1.000 |
Li et al. (2015) China [22] | RCT (Jan. 2006-Dec. 2013) | 34/34 (EEN/PN) | 67.7 ± 7.2 (range: 60-86) | I, II, IIIa, IIIb |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EN (16.2 ± 3.6) - PN (19.7 ± 4.5) - p < 0.001 2) Time until flatus (days) - EN (2.2 ± 0.3) - PN (3.7 ± 0.5) - p < 0.001 |
1) Incidence of complications | 1) 29 (10.6)/38 (14.0); ns |
Li et al. (2015) China [24] | RCT (Jul. 2010-May. 2014) | 150/150 (EEN/TP) |
EEN (59.2 ± 9.7) TP (60.4 ± 9.2) TP (nasoenteral feeding tube & postoperative intravenous infusion) |
- |
1) Hospital stay (days) - EEN (7.73 ± 2.13) - TP (9.77 ± 1.76) - p = 0.002 2) Time until flatus (hr) - EEN (78.8 ± 9.3) - TP (85.3 ± 8.4) - p = 0.011 |
1) Incidence of complications 2) Fever duration (hr) |
1) 21 (14.0)/26 (17.3); p = 0.232 2) 80.2 ± 6.0/88.1 ± 8.1; p = 0.012 |
Enternal immunonutrition (ID) vs. Isocaloric-isonitrogenous formula (IF) | |||||||
Farreras et al. (2005) Spain [25] | RCT (Jan. 1999-Sep. 2000) | 30/30 (ID/IF) |
ID (66.7 ± 8.3) IF (69.2 ± 13.8) |
Gastric adenocarcinoma |
1) Hospital stay (days) - ID [13] - IF [15] - p = 0.02 2) Mortality - ID (1 [3.3]) - IF (2 [6.7]) - ns |
1) Wound-healing complications 2) Suture failure 3) Infectious complications 4) Global complications 5) Dehiscence 6) Evisceration 7) Surgical wound infection 8) Intraabdominal abscess 9) Sepsis 10) Pneumonia 11) Urinary tract infection |
1) 0 (0)/8 (26.7); p = 0.005 2) 0 (0)/5 (16.6); p = 0.03 3) 2 (6.7)/9 (30); p = 0.01 4) 4 (13.3)/13 (43.3); p = 0.01 5) 0/2 (6.7); ns 6) 0/1 (3.3); ns 7) 1 (3.3)/4 (13.3); ns 8) 0/1 (3.3); ns 9) 0/0 10) 0/2 (6.7); ns 11) 1 (3.3)/2 (6.7); ns |
Enternal immunonutrition (ID) vs. Isocaloric-isonitrogenous formula (IF) | |||||||
Marano et al. (2013) Italy [26] | RCT (2006-2011) | 54/55 (ID/IF) |
ID (66.6) IF (65.1) (range: 55-78) |
Gastric adeno-carcinoma (T1-T4) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - ID (12.7 ± 2.3) - IF (15.9 ± 3.4) - p = 0.029 2) Mortality - ID (1 [1.8]) - IF (1 [1.8]) - p = 0.325 |
1) Infectious complications - wound infection - respiratory tract infection - urinary tract infection - sepsis 2) Anastomotic leakage 3) SIRS (days) |
1) 4 (7.4)/11 (20); p = 0.041 - 1 (1.8)/3 (5.4) - 2 (3.7)/5 (9) - 1 (1.8)/2 (3.6) - 0/1 (1.8) 2) 2 (3.7)/4 (7.3); p = 0.045 3) 1.1 ± 0.89/2.2 ± 1.02; p = 0.036 |
Parental nutrition (PN) vs. Intravenous fluids (IVF) & Soybean oil | |||||||
Ryan et al. (2007) UK [27] | Retrospective (Feb. 1998-Oct. 2006) | 38/52 (TPN/IVF) | 65 ± 12 (range: 26-85) | Gastric adenocarcinoma, GIST, lymphoma |
1) Hospital stay (days) - TPN (21.8 ± 20) - IVF (17.6 ± 8.6) - p = 0.184 2) Weight loss - TPN (-3.8 kg) - IVF (-5.2 kg) - p = 0.008 |
1) Any complication 2) Wound infection 3) Multiple organ failure 4) Respiratory failure 5) Mortality 6) Pneumonia 7) Sepsis |
1) 43.2/27.5; p = 0.189 2) 2.7/5.9; p = 0.636 3) 2.7/0; p = 0.42 4) 8.1/2.0; p = 0.305 5) 8.1/0; p = 0.071 6) 8.1/7.8; p = 1.000 7) 16.2/5.9; p = 0.158 |
Wei et al. (2014) China [28] | RCT (May. 2007-May. 2008) | 26/20 (PN/CT) |
PN (50.5, median) (range: 29-75) CT (59, median) (range: 36-74) |
TNM I-II |
1) Total complications - incisional wound infection - abdominal infection - urinary infection - pulmonary infection |
1) 1/6; p = 0.033 - 1/3; p = 0.303 - 0/1; p = 0.435 - 0/1; p = 0.435 - 0/1; p = 0.435 |
Table 3
Author (year, country) | Study type | Population (N) | Age (years, mean ± S.D) | Cancer type (stage) | Nutritional status measurement (indicator) | Clinical outcomes (mean ± S.D, N [%]) | Complications | Result (experimental vs. control group [N (%)]) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Nutritional intervention & assessment | ||||||||
Lee et al. (2002) Korea [29] | RCT (Oct. 1999-Dec. 2000) | 22/18 (NC/NNC) |
NC (54.1 [± 11.4]) NNC (57.6 [± 12.0]) |
EGC (T1N0/T1N1) | NC (6-24 months, postoperatively) |
1) Weight loss (kg) - NC (-8.6) - NNC (-6.6) - ns |
- | - |
Nakanoko et al. (2015) Japan [30] | Retrospective (1998-2008) | 430/41 (< 80/≥ 80yrs) |
< 80yrs (62, median) ≥ 80yrs (82.1, median) |
Gastric adeno-carcinoma (I-IV, T1-T4) | WL[NA] (> 1 yr period, postoperatively; < 80yrs[-6.0 ± 7.4] ≥ 80yrs[-6.8 ± 5.3]) |
1) Overall survival - < 80 yrs (72.9) - ≥ 80 yrs (48.8) - p = 0.032 2) 5-year cumulative survival - < 80 yrs (78.2) - ≥ 80 yrs (81.8) - p = 0.963 |
1) Surgery related (%) - pancreatic-related abscess - anastomotic leakage - bleeding - others 2) Non-surgery related (%) - pneumonia - cardiovascular dysfunction - delirium - others 3) Total complications |
1) ns - 11 (2.6)/0 - 7 (1.5)/0 - 2 (0.4)/0 - 12 (2.8)/1 (2.4) 2) ns - 1 (0.2)/0 - 0/1 (2.4) - 10 (2.3)/1 (2.4) - 8 (1.9)/2 (4.9) 3) 55 (12.8)/4 (9.8); ns |
So et al. (2008) Singapore [31] | Cohort (Jan. 2000-Apr. 2005) | 61/54 (PG/PPG) |
PG (66.3) PPG (63.7) |
AJCC (0-4) |
Clinical pathway PG (multidisciplinary program: preoperative education & counseling, pain control, physiotherapy, nutritional support, surgical care) |
1) Hospital stay (days, mean) - PG (11.29) - PPG (14.04) - p = 0.023 2) Re-admission rate (30-day) - PG (11 [18]) - PPG (7 [13.0]) - p = 0.455 3) Mortality - PG (0 [0]) - PPG (3 [5.6]) - p = 0.062 |
1) Complication rate |
1) p = 0.960 - PG (24 [39.3]) - PPG (21 [38.9]) |
Nutritional screening tool (malnourished vs. non-malnourished) | ||||||||
Oh et al. (2012) Korea [32] | Retrospective (Jan. 2008-Jun. 2008) |
Total (669) NRI < 97.5 (N = 566) NRI ≥ 97.5 (N = 103) |
All (56.77 ± 11.4) NRI < 97.5 (57.15 ± 11.7) NRI ≥ 97.5 (54.70 ± 9.6) |
Gastric adeno-carcinoma (EGC/AGC) |
NRI < 97.5 (malnourished) NRI ≥ 97.5 (non-malnourished) |
1) Hospital stay (days) - NRI < 97.5 (12.76 ± 4.02) - NRI ≥ 97.5 (12.01 ± 2.45) - p = 0.160 |
1) Comorbid diseases - hypertension - diabetes mellitus - pulmonary tuberculosis - cardiovascular diseases - hepatitis - others 2) Wound complication |
1) p = 0.365 - 130 (23)/29 (28.1) - 66 (11.7)/20 (19.4) - 22 (3.9)/7 (6.8) - 13 (2.3)/3 (2.9) - 40 (7.1)/5 (4.8) - 18 (3)/1 (1) 2) 62 (10.9)/4 (3.8); p = 0.027 |
Qiu et al. (2014) China [33] | RCT (2012-2013) |
Total (830) NRS < 3 (279M/139F) NRS ≥ 3 (269M/152F) |
≤ 59 > 59 |
Gastric adeno-carcinoma (TNM I-IV) |
NRS < 3 (low malnourished risk group) NRS ≥ 3 (high malnourished risk group) |
1) Survival (median) - NRS < 3 (31.9 months) - NRS ≥ 3 (25.7 months) - p < 0.001 |
- | - |
NC: nutritional counseling group, NNC: non-nutritional counseling group, PPG: pre-pathway group, PG: pathway group, EGC: early gastric cancer, AGC: advanced gastric cancer, AJCC: American Joint Committee on Cancer, TNM: tumor-node-metastasis, NRI: nutritional risk index, NRS: nutritional risk screening, NA: nutritional assessment, WL: weight loss, ns: not significant, M: male, F: female, RCT: randomized controlled trial.