Journal List > Korean J Schizophr Res > v.19(2) > 1057829

Maeng, Kim, Kim, Bae, Lee, and Kim: Factors Affecting Quality of Life and Family Burden among the Families of Patients with Schizophrenia

Abstract

Objectives

Study aimed to identify factors that may affect family burden and quality of life (QOL) of primary caregivers in schizophrenia family.

Methods

Among outpatients with schizophrenia undergoing treatment at the psychiatric department of a university hospital, 72 patients and their primary caregivers were investigated. Sociodemographic and clinical data were collected and analyzed.

Results

: As a result of multiple regression of primary caregivers' family burden (R2=0.284), primary caregiver's income (p=0.001) and patient's delusional symptoms (p=0.001) significantly explained the total family burden of primary caregivers. In multiple regression on QOL (R2=0.515), primary caregiver's income (p=0.033) and education level (p=0.006), patient's sex (p=0.006), treatment duration (p<0.001), degree of disorganized speech (p=0.008), negative drug attitudes (p=0.026) and the attitude of overcoming stigma against mental patients (p=0.029) all significantly explained the average QOL score.

Conclusion

: Various factors determining primary caregiver's QOL, including Clinical symptoms such as patient's disorganized speech and clinically correctable factors such as negative drug attitude and insight into disease. Therefore, provision of education regarding drug and disease for patients and caregivers will be helpful to effectively reduce burden and improve the QOL of primary caregivers.

References

1. Lee JS, Kim KI, Oh DY. Family's burden of psychotic in-patient. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 1991 May; 30:517–531.
2. Lefley HP. Family burden and family stigma in major mental illness. Am Psychol. 1989 Mar; 44:556–560.
crossref
3. Scazufca M, Kuipers E. Links between expressed emotion and burden of care in relatives of patients with schizophrenia. Br J Psychiatry. 1996; 168:580–587.
crossref
4. Rössler W, Salize HJ, Cucchiaro G, Reinhard I, Kernig C. Does the place of treatment influence the quality of life of schizophrenics? Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1999; 100:142–148.
crossref
5. Hoenig J, Hamilton MW. The schizophrenic patient in the community and his effect on the household. Int J Soc Psychiatry. 1966; 12:165–176.
crossref
6. Dillehay R, Sandys M. Caregivers for Alzheimer's patients: What we are learning from research? Int J Aging Hum Dev. 1990; 30:263–285.
crossref
7. Provencher HL, Mueser KT. Positive and negative symptom behaviors and caregiver burden in the relatives of persons with schizophrenia. Schizophr Res. 1997; 26:71–80.
crossref
8. Schene AH, Van Wijngaarden B, Koeter MW. Family caregiving in schizophrenia: Domains and distress. Schizophr Bull. 1998; 24:609–618.
crossref
9. Woltraus J, Dingemans P, Schene A, Linszen D, Wiersma D, Van Den B, et al. Caregiver burden in recent-onset schizophrenia and spectrum disorders: The influence of symptoms and personality traits. J Nerv Ment Dis. 2002; 190:241–247.
10. Wu E, Birnbaum H, Shi L, Ball D, Kessler R, Moulis M, et al. The economic burden of schizophrenia in the United States in 2002. J Clin Psychiatry. 2005; 66:1122–1129.
crossref
11. Knapp M, Mangalore R, Simon J. The global costs of schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull. 2004; 30:279–293.
crossref
12. Foldemo A, Gullberg M, Ek AC, Bogren L. Quality of life and burden in parents of outpatients with schizophrenia. Soc Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2005; 40:133–138.
crossref
13. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders. 5th ed. Washington DC, American Psychiatric Association;2013.
14. Kim CK, Seo JM, Lee GZ, Kim JW, Kim GJ, Byun WT. Family burden of schizophrenics in the primary caregivers and siblings. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2000; 39:113–127.
15. Yoon BH, Bahk WM, Lee KU, Hong CH, Ahn JK, Kim MK. Psychometric properties of Korean version of drug attitude inventory (KDAI-10). Korean J Psychoparmacol. 2005; 16:480–487.
16. Hwang TY, Lee WK, Han ES, Kwon EJ. A study on the reliability and validity of the Korean version of internalized stigma of mental illness scale (K-ISMI). J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2006; 45:418–426.
17. Chung S, Bahk WM, Kwon JS, Park JH, Ahn JH, Goh J, et al. Symptom remission and functional outcomes in patients with recent-onset schizophrenia: A one-year prospective observational study. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2007; 46:480–491.
18. Haro JM, Kamath SA, Ochoa S, Novick D, Rele K, Fargas A, et al. The Clinical Global Impression-Schizophrenia scale: A simple instrument to measure the diversity of symptoms present in schizophrenia. Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl. 2003; 416:16–23.
crossref
19. Song JY, Kim KT, Lee SK, Kim YH, Noh JH, Kim JW, et al. Reliability and validity of the Korean version of the scale to assessment unawareness of mental disorder (SUMD-K). J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2006; 45:307–315.
20. Kim CK, Cho JS, Seo JM, Kim YK, Kim HC, Kim HS, et al. A preliminary study for the development of the family burden scale of the schizophrenia. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 1999; 38:539–553.
21. Min SK, Lee CI, Kim KI, Suh SY, Kim DK. Development of Korean version of WHO quality of life scale abbreviated version (WHO-QOL-BREF). J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2000; 39:571–579.
22. Sadock BJ, Sadock VA. Kaplan and Sadock's synopsis of psychiatry: Behavioral sciences/clinical psychiatry. 10th ed.Lippincott Williams & Wilkins;2011. p. p467–488.
23. Gopinath PS, Chaturvedi SK. Distressing behavior of schizophrenics at home. Acta Psychiatr Scand. 1992; 86:185–188.
24. Noh S, Turner BJ. Living with psychiatric patients: Implications for the mental health of family members. Soc Sci Med. 1987; 25:263–271.
crossref
25. Gibbons JS, Horn SH, Powell JM, Gibbons JL. Schizophrenic patients and their families. A survey in a psychiatric service based on a DGH unit. Br J Psychiatry. 1984; 144:70–77.
crossref
26. Alejandra CU, Jose GM, Claudia MC. Quality of life in caregivers of patients with schizophrenia: A literature review. Health Qual Life Out. 2009; 7:84.
crossref
27. Kwang DH, Kim CH, Byun WT. The objective and subjective family burden of schizophrenic patient. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 1995; 34:193–203.
28. Sibitz I, Unger A, Woppmann A, Zidek T, Amering M. Stigma resistance in patients with schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull. 2011; 37:316–323.
crossref

Fig. 1.
Flow chart of study participants.
kjsr-19-78f1.tif
Table 1.
Sociodemographic characteristics of the patients with schizophrenia
  Schizophrenia (N=72)
N (%)
Sex
Male 36 (50)0.
Female 36 (50)0.
Age
≤ 29 15 (20.3)
30–39 16 (22.2)
400–49 16 (22.2)
500–59 17 (23.6)
≥ 60 8 (11.1)
Education
High school graduate or less 35 (48.6)
Some college or more 37 (51.4)
Marriage
Married 12 (16.7)
Never married 51 (70.8)
Others∗ 9 (12.5)
Employment
Unemployed 56 (77.8)
Employed 16 (22.2)
Living arrangement
Living alone 11 (15.3)
Living with someone 61 (84.7)
Experience of community mental health program
Yes 22 (30.6)
No 50 (69.4)

: cohabitation, divorce or widowed,†: living with family or residential psychiatric rehabilitation facility members,‡: community mental health center, family therapy or self-help group programs

Table 2.
Sociodemographic characteristics of primary caregiv ers of patients with schizophrenia
  Primary caregiver (N=72)
N (%)
Sex
Male 35 (48.6)
Female 37 (51.4)
Age
≤29 1 (1.4)
30–39 4 (5.6)
40–49 7 (9.7)
50–59 31 (43.1)
≥60 28 (39.4)
Education
High school graduate or less 46 (63.9)
Some college or more 26 (36.1)
Marriage
Married 47 (65.3)
Never married 10 (13.9)
Others∗ 15 (20.8)
Employment
Unemployed 32 (44.4)
Employed 40 (55.6)
Total monthly income (Won)
<500,000 29 (40.3)
500,000–2,000,000 37 (51.4)
>2,000,000 6 (8.3)
Relationship with patient
Father 27 (37.5)
Mother 13 (18.1)
Spouse 9 (12.5)
Sibling 14 (19.4)
Offspring 9 (12.5)
Living with patien
Yes 52 (72.2)
No 20 (27.8)
Experience of community mental health program
Yes 20 (27.8)
No 52 (72.2)
∗: cohabitation, divorce or wido health center, family therapy or se owed,†: community menta elf-help group programs
Table 3.
Clinical characteristics of the patients with schizophre nia
  Schizophrenia (N=72)
N (%)
Duration of diagnosis (years)
<1 yr 7 (9.7)
1–5 yr 18 (25.0)
6–10 yr 10 (13.9)
≥11 yr 37 (51.4)
Duration of treatment (years)
<1 yr 9 (12.5)
1–5 yr 19 (26.4)
6–10 yr 12 (16.7)
≥11 yr 32 (44.4)
Number of admission
None 8 (11.1)
1–2 38 (52.8)
3–5 17 (23.6)
≥6 9 (12.5)
Number of outpatient visit for 3 months past
<3 29 (40.3)
3–5 40 (55.6)
≥6 3 (4.2)
Number of comorbid physical illness
Yes 18 (25.0)
No 54 (75.0)
  Mean (SD)
KDAI-10
Subjective positive feeling 2.06 (3.75)
Subjective negative feeling –1.50 (2.51)0.
FS (Final score) 3.56 (5.21)
K-ISMI
Alienation 13.81 (3.56)0
Stereotype endorsement 14.51 (2.85)0
Discrimination experience 10.36 (2.45)0
Social withdrawal 13.14 (3.17)0
Stigma resistance 12.31 (2.64)0
Total score 39.51 (9.94)0
DSM-5 CRDPSS
Hallucination 1.75 (0.90)
Delusion 1.97 (0.77)
Disorganized speech 1.53 (0.84)
Abnormal psychomotor behavior 1.18 (0.68)
Negative symptoms 1.85 (0.74)
Impaired cognition 1.85 (0.76)
CGI-S 3.40 (0.85)
GAF 52.44 (13.44)
K-SUMD
Awareness of mental disorder 1.86 (0.68)
Awareness of social consequences 1.97 (0.73)
Awareness of medication effects 1.78 (0.74)
Awareness of positive symptoms 5.99 (2.17)
Awareness of negative symptoms 6.21 (1.79)
Total score 17.81 (4.99)0

KDAI-10: Korean version of Drug Attitude Inventory-10, K-ISMI: Korean version of Internalized stigma of mental illness scale, DSM-5 CRDPSS: DSM-5 Clinician-Rated Dimensions of Psychosis Symptom Severity, CGI-S: Clinical Global Impression-Severity, GAF: Global Assessment of Functioning, K-SUMD: Korean version of Scale to Assess Unawareness of Mental disorder

Table 4.
Clinical characteristics of primary caregivers of patients with schizophrenia
  Primary caregiver (N=72)
N (%)
FBS
Total score 42.00 (26.07)
Objective burden 12.44 (10.20)
Subjective burden 29.56 (17.30)
WHOQOL-BREF
Physical health domain 21.97 (5.25)
Psychological domain 16.67 (3.78)
Social relationships domain 8.47 (2.51)
Environmental domain 21.71 (4.90)
Overall QOL domain 5.61 (1.42)
Total score 74.42 (14.76)
QOL score (Average) 2.98 (0.59)

FBS: Family Burden Scale, WHOQOL-BREF: World Health Organization Quality of Life Assessment Instrument abbreviated version

Table 5.
Effect of variables of patients with schizophrenia on the familial burden score and quality of life of primary caregivers
  FBS (Total score) FBS (Objective) FBS (Subjective) QOL score
Mean (SD) F Mean (SD) F Mean (SD) F Mean (SD) F
Sex
Male 42.72 (27.57) 0.055 13.47 (11.12) 0.728 29.25 (18.14) 0.022 2.79(0.55) ∗7.481∗
Female 41.28 (24.86) 11.42 (9.23) 29.86 (16.67) 3.16 (0.58)
Age
≤29 41.20 (29.78)   12.80 (11.23)   28.40 (19.06)   3.33 (0.44)  
30–39 44.69 (25.46)   11.00 (10.69)   33.69 (17.44)   2.73 (0.56)  
40–49 48.69 (31.00) 0.626 15.06 (11.88) 0.391 33.63 (19.89) 1.021 2.87 (0.57) 4.198
50–59 34.88 (13.12)   11.53 (6.86)   23.35 (7.83)   3.18 (0.53)  
≥60 39.88 (32.12)   11.38 (11.16)   28.50 (22.24)   2.59 (0.65)  
Education
≤High school graduate 41.80 (23.29) 0.004 13.09 (8.91) 0.266 28.71 (15.60) 0.159 2.95 (0.60) 0.152
Some college or more 42.19 (28.78) 11.84 (11.37) 30.35 (18.95) 3.00 (0.60)
Marriage
Married 42.83 (22.42)   12.17 (7.91)   30.67 (15.48)   3.11 (0.68)  
Never married 44.82 (27.69) 2.327 13.63 (11.05) 2.150 31.20 (18.16) 2.061 2.96 (0.60) 0.438
Others 24.89 (13.00)   6.11 (4.46)   18.78 (10.77)   2.87 (0.38)  
Living Arrangement                
Living alone 40.67 (34.21) 0.037 11.75 (12.93) 0.066 28.92 (22.01) 0.019 3.11 (0.65) 0.695
Living with someone§ 42.27 (24.48) 12.58 (9.69) 29.68 (16.42) 2.95 (0.58)
Experience of community mental health program
No 41.46 (26.44) 0.069 11.66 (10.36) 0.967 29.80 (17.57) 0.032 3.03 (0.59) 1.202
Yes 43.23 (25.80)   14.23 (9.83)   29.00 (17.06) 2.86 (0.58)
Duration of diagnosis (years)
<1 yr 33.29 (7.06)   8.43 (4.11)   24.86 (5.64)   3.21 (0.52)  
1–5 yr 35.17 (27.62) 1.028 10.33 (10.52) 1.028 24.83 (17.78) 0.974 3.30 (0.47) ∗3.814∗
6–10 yr 46.20 (36.35) 15.50 (12.71) 30.70 (24.26) 2.71 (0.75)
≥11 yr 45.84 (24.16)   13.41 (10.04)   32.43 (16.25)   2.85 (0.55)  
Duration of treatment (years)
<1 yr 40.67 (16.31)   10.44 (5.50)   30.22 (11.98)   3.20 (0.48)  
1–5 yr 34.53 (26.99) 0.827 10.32 (10.22) 0.630 24.21 (17.50) 0.929 3.30 (0.45) ∗4.407∗
6–10 yr 43.25 (33.09) 13.75 (12.08) 29.50 (22.09) 2.75 (0.76)
≥11 yr 46.34 (24.94)   13.78 (10.56)   32.56 (16.45)   2.81 (0.54)  
Number of admission
None 45.25 (23.47)   15.50 (8.40)   29.75 (16.18)   3.07 (0.56)  
1–2 39.68 (27.92) 0.583 11.03 (10.63) 1.012 28.66 (18.44) 0.369 3.06 (0.60) 0.897
3–5 40.41 (26.47) 11.94 (10.55) 28.47 (17.51) 2.83 (0.63)
≥6 51.89 (19.82)   16.67 (8.78)   35.22 (14.09)   2.81 (0.53)  
Number of outpatient visit (for 3 months past)
1–2 43.14 (26.05)   12.83 (9.88)   30.31 (17.99)   2.95 (0.53)  
3–5 40.23 (24.90) 0.467 11.85 (10.00) 0.339 28.38 (16.19) 0.471 3.02 (0.64) 0.667
≥6 54.67 (47.17)   16.67 (18.45)   38.00 (29.00)   2.63 (0.61)  
Comorbid physical illness
No 44.96 (28.71) 2.863 13.69 (10.99) 3.299 31.28 (18.98) 2.176 2.98 (0.63) 0.001
Yes 33.11 (12.61) 8.72 (6.18) 24.39 (9.46) 2.97 (0.47)

: statistically significant p value (<0.05),†: statistically significant p value (<0.005),‡: cohabitation, divorce or widowed, §: living with family or residential psychiatric rehabilitation facility members, ¶: community mental health center, family therapy or self-help group programs

Table 6.
Effect of variables of primary caregivers on the familial burden score and quality of life of primary caregivers
  FBS (Total score) FBS (Objective) FBS (Subjective) QOL score
Mean (SD) F Mean (SD) F Mean (SD) F Mean (SD) F
Sex
Male 33.09 (19.78) 8.840 9.66 (7.91) ∗5.400∗ 23.43 (13.60) 9.575 3.04 (0.54) 0.698
Female 50.43 (28.65) 15.08 (11.46) 35.35 (18.56) 2.92 (0.64)
Age
≤29 31.00 (0.00)   9.00 (0.00)   22.00 (0.00)   3.32 (0.00)  
30–39 32.00 (20.69)   13.25 (10.08)   18.75 (10.69)   3.47 (0.61)  
40–49 41.29 (32.58) 0.393 13.00 (11.27) 0.080 28.29 (21.85) 0.820 2.88 (0.77) 4.713
50–59 39.06 (26.13)   11.55 (10.30)   27.52 (16.50)   3.21 (0.46)  
≥60 45.29 (24.36)   32.89 (17.25)   32.89 (17.25)   2.67 (0.55)  
Education
≤High school graduate 46.30 (28.17) 3.599 13.67 (11.09) 1.873 32.63 (18.70) 4.206∗ 2.81 (0.57) 12.472†.
Some college or more 34.38 (20.21) 10.27 (8.16) 24.12 (13.13) 3.28 (0.50)
Marriage
Married 37.79 (22.10)   10.70 (8.43)   27.09 (15.42)   3.13 (0.54)  
Never married 41.90 (30.27) 2.676 14.40 (10.73) 2.185 27.50 (20.16) 2.761 2.96 (0.62) 7.403
Others 55.27 (31.72)   16.60 (13.74)   38.67 (19.04)   2.51 (0.51)  
Employment
Unemployed 46.88 (27.96) 2.043 13.69 (10.89) 0.854 33.19 (18.48) 2.596 2.85 (0.67) 2.714
Employed 38.10 (24.11) 11.45 (9.64) 26.65 (15.93) 3.08 (0.50)
Total monthly income (Won)
<500,000 56.00 (31.33)   17.03 (12.45)   38.97 (20.14)   2.68 (0.62)  
500,000–2,000,000 33.22 (17.46) 8.601 9.76 (7.26) 5.825 23.46 (12.39) 8.795 3.14 (0.49) 7.961
>2,000,000 28.50 (5.89)   6.83 (4.07)   21.67 (3.14)   3.41 (0.35)  
Relationship with patient
Father 50.93 (27.74)   14.59 (11.16)   36.33 (17.70)   2.92 (0.58)  
Mother 34.77 (27.20)   9.77 (9.79)   25.00 (19.82)   2.89 (0.64)  
Spouse 34.33 (6.78) 1.438 10.33 (3.81) 0.649 24.00 (4.64) 1.856 3.14 (0.55) 0.483
Sibling 36.29 (19.04)   11.57 (9.10)   24.71 (11.96)   3.11 (0.59)  
Offspring 42.22 (36.21)   13.33 (13.84)   28.89 (23.06)   2.93 (0.65)  
Living with patient
Yes 43.65 (27.13) 0.751 12.81 (10.33) 0.235 30.85 (18.14) 1.043 2.97 (0.63) 0.018
No 37.70 (23.18) 11.50 (10.06) 26.20 (14.80) 2.99 (0.47)
Experience of community mental health program§
No 41.91 (24.68) 0.003 11.60 (9.26) 1.915 30.32 (16.88) 0.525 3.00 (0.61) 0.398
Yes 42.33 (31.79) 15.67 (13.07) 26.67 (19.14) 2.89 (0.53)

: statistically significant p value (<0.05),†: statistically significant p value (<0.005),‡: cohabitation, divorce or widowed, §: community mental health center, family therapy or self-help group programs

Table 7.
Caregiver burden of variable selection by stepwise
  Parameter Estimate Standard Error t value p
FBS, total score (R2=0.284) <0.001
Caregiver, income –15.022- 4.115 –3.650- 0.001
Patient, CRDPSS (delusion) 11.365 3.347 3.395 0.001
FBS, objective burden (R2=0.218) <0.001
Caregiver, income 0–4.768- 1.734 –2.750- 0.008
Patient, CRDPSS (delusion) 03.111 1.428 2.178 0.033
FBS, subjective burden (R2=0.322) <0.001
Caregiver, income –10.348- 2.709 –3.820- <0.001
Patient, CRDPSS (delusion) 08.916 2.297 3.882 <0.001
Caregiver, sex (female) 02.127 0.979 2.174 0.033

FBS: Family Burden Scale, CRDPSS: DSM-5 Clinician-Rated Dimensions of Psychosis Symptom Severity

Table 8.
Caregiver quality of life of variable selection by stepwise
  Parameter Estimate Standard Error t value p
Average QOL score (R2=0.515) <0.001
Caregiver, income 0.203 0.093 2.181 0.033
Caregiver, education 0.322 0.112 2.870 0.006
Patient, sex (female) 0.304 0.108 2.821 0.006
Patient, treatment duration –0.175- 0.046 –3.776- <0.001
Patient, CRDPSS (disorganized speech) –0.111- 0.063 –1.756- 0.008
Patient, KDAI-10 (negative) –0.049- 0.022 –2.273- 0.026
Patient, K-ISMI (stigma resistance) 0.046 0.021 2.227 0.029
QOL-Physical health (R2=0.508) <0.001
Caregiver, education 2.478 0.953 2.599 0.012
Caregiver, sex (female) –3.479- 0.938 –3.708- <0.001
Patient, sex (female) 4.150 0.936 4.433 <0.001
Patient, treatment duration –1.532- 0.412 –3.718- <0.001
Patient, KDAI-10 (negative) –0.555- 0.182 –3.046- 0.003
Patient, K-ISMI (stigma resistance) 0.496 0.177 2.804 0.007
QOL-Psychological (R2=0.178) <0.001
Caregiver, income 2.591 0.661 3.921 <0.001
QOL-Social relationships (R2=0.276) <0.001
Patient, diagnosis duration –0.768- 0.241 –3.189- 0.002
Patient, CRDPSS (disorganized speech) –0.649- 0.313 –2.075- 0.042
Patient, KDAI-10 (negative) –0.308- 0.104 –2.959- 0.004
QOL-Environmental (R2=0.352) <0.001
Caregiver, education 3.896 0.977 3.987 <0.001
Patient, treatment duration –1.865- 0.440 –4.237- <0.001
Patient, K-SUMD (positive symptom awareness) –0.668- 0.224 –2.983- 0.004

CRDPSS: DSM-5 Clinician-Rated Dimensions of Psychosis Symptom Severity, KDAI-10: Korean version of Drug Attitude Inventory-10, K-ISMI: Korean version of Internalized stigma of mental illness scale, K-SUMD: Scale to Assess Unawareness of Mental disorder-short form

TOOLS
Similar articles