Journal List > Korean J Orthod > v.40(4) > 1043628

The effect of growth hormone treatment on craniofacial growth in short stature children

Abstract

Objective:

The purpose of this study was to analyze the effect of growth hormone treatment (GHT) on craniofacial growth in children of short stature.

Methods:

Nineteen untreated children of short stature were referred from the Pediatric Department, Yeungnam University Hospital as a subject group. All subjects had lateral cephalograms taken before, after 1 year and after 2 years of growth hormone treatment. As a reference group, we selected 19 normal children with paired sampling who matched the subjects' age and sex, from the Department of Orthodontics, Kyungpook National University Hospital.

Results:

Before GHT, anterior cranial base length and upper posterior facial height, posterior total facial height, mandibular ramus length, and mandibular corpus length were significantly smaller in the reference group. In angular craniofacial measurements, saddle angle and mandibular plane angle were larger. SNA and SNB were smaller in the reference group. After two years of GHT, growth hormone accelerated growth in several craniofacial components. The posterior total facial height, the anterior, posterior cranial base length, and the mandibular ramus length were increased. And the difference in mandibular plane angle and ANB values compared with the reference group was decreased.

Conclusions:

GHT over 2 years leads to a craniofacial catch-up growth tendency, which is pronounced in interstitial cartilage and condylar cartilage.

REFERENCES

1.Brown T. Skeletal maturity and facial growth assessment. Aust Orthod J. 1970. 2:80–7.
2.Scammon RE. Measurement of the body in childhood. In: Harris JA, Jackson CM, Patterson DG, Scammon RE editors. The measurement of man. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota;1930.
3.Cohen P., Rogol AD., Deal CL., Saenger P., Reiter EO., Ross JL, et al. Consensus statement on the diagnosis and treatment of children with idiopathic short stature: a summary of the Growth Hormone Research Society, the Lawson Wilkins Pediatric Endocrine Society, and the European Society for Paediatric Endocrinology Workshop. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2008. 93:4210–7.
crossref
4.Spiegel RN., Sather AH., Hayles AB. Cephalometric study of childeren with various endocrine diseases. Am J Orthod. 1971. 59:362–75.
5.Kjellberg H., Beiring M., Wikland KA. Craniofacial morphology, dental occlusion, tooth eruption, and dental maturity in boys of short stature with or without growth hormone deficiency. Eur J Oral Sci. 2000. 108:359–67.
crossref
6.Hwang CJ., Cha JY. Orthodontic treatment with growth hormone therapy in a girl of short stature. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2004. 126:118–26.
crossref
7.Nanda RS. The rate of growth of several facial components measured from serial cephalometric roentgenograms. Am J Orthod. 1955. 41:658–73.
8.Björk A., Helm S. Prediction of the age of maximum pubertal growth in body height. Angle Orthod. 1967. 37:134–43.
9.Baughan B., Demirjian A., Levesque GY., Lapalme-Chaput L. The pattern of facial growth before and during puberty, as shown by French-Canadian girls. Ann Hum Biol. 1979. 6:59–76.
crossref
10.Isaksoon OG., Lindahl A., Nilsson A., Isgaard J. Mechanism of the stimulatory effect of growth hormone on longitudinal bone growth. Endocr Rev. 1987. 8:426–38.
11.Bajpai A., Menon PS. Growth hormone therapy. Indian J Pediatr. 2005. 72:139–44.
crossref
12.Rongen-Westerlaken C., vd Born E., Prahl-Andersen B., von Teunenbroek A., Manesse P., Otten BJ, et al. Effect of growth hormone treatment on craniofacial growth in Turner's syndrome. Acta Paediatr. 1993. 82:364–8.
crossref
13.Bergersen EO. The male adolescent facial growth spurt: its prediction and relation to skeletal maturation. Angle Orthod. 1972. 42:319–38.
14.Graber TM. Orthodontics: principles and practice. 3rd ed.Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders;1972. p. 27–128.
15.Coben SE. Growth concepts. Angle Orthod. 1961. 31:194–201.
16.Sohn BW., Kim HS. A semilongitudinal study on cranial base, maxillary and mandibular growth of Korean children aging 7 to 17 years old. Korean J Orthod. 1999. 29:23–35.
17.Hunter CJ. The correlation of facial growth with body height and skeletal maturation at adolescence. Angle Orthod. 1966. 36:44–54.
18.Van Erum R., Mulier M., Carels C. Verbeke G, de Zegher F. Craniofacial growth in short children born small for gestational age: effect of growth hormone treatment. J Dent Res. 1997. 76:1579–86.
19.Pirinen S., Majurin A., Lenko HL., Koski K. Craniofacial features in patients with deficient and excessive growth hormone. J Craniofac Genet Dev Biol. 1994. 14:144–52.
20.Ranly DM. A synopsis of craniofacial growth. 2nd ed.Norwalk, Conn.: Appleton & Lange;1984. p. 124–41.
21.Tanaka T., Satoh M., Yasunaga T., Horikawa R., Tanae A., Katsumata N, et al. When and how to combine growth hormone with a luteinizing hormone-releasing hormone analogue. Acta Paediatr Suppl. 1999. 88:85–8.
crossref

Fig 1.
Cephalometric landmarks.
kjod-40-227f1.tif
Table 1.
Demographic characteristics of subjects at baseline
  Childrenof shortstature (n=19) Childrenof normalstature (n=19)
Sex Male(%) 8(42.1) 8(42.1)
Female(%) 11(57.9) 11(57.9)
Age 9-11years( (%) 11(57.9) 11(57.9)
12-15years (%) 8(42.1) 8(42.1)
Mean(SD) 11.63(1.89) 11.63(1.89)
Table 2.
Linear and angular craniofacial measurements
Linear Abbreviation Cephalometric landmarks Angular Abbreviation Cephalometric landmarks
Anterior cranial base length ACB N-S Saddle angle SA N-S-Art
Posterior cranial base length PCB S-Ba Gonialangle GA Art-Go-Me
Total cranial base length TCB N-Ba Mandibular plane angle MPA S-N-Go-Gn
Upper anterior facial height UAFH N-ANS Position of maxilla SNA S-N-A
Upper posterior facial height UPFH S-PNS Position of mandible SNB S-N-B
Lower anterior facial height LAFH ANS-Me Maxilla/mandible ANB A-N-B
Anterior total facial height ATFH N-Me Posterior position of mandib ble PPMand S-N-Art-Go
Posteriortotalfacialheight PTFH S-Go Maxilla length MaxL ANS-PNS
Mandibular ramus length MandRL Art-Go      
Mandibular corpus length MandCL Go-Pog      
Overall mandibular length OMandL Art-Pog      
Table 3.
Comparison of raw mean (standard error, SE) for the z scores of weight and height, bone mass index (BMI), and bone age from baseline to after 2 years in children of short stature by age groups
Agegroup Atbaseline(n=19) Mean(SE) After1year(n=19) Mean(SE) After2years(n=19 Mean(SE) ) pa
9-11years(n=11)        
 Weight(kg) 26.13(1.09) 32.68(1.32)b 40.63(1.92)c 0.001
 Weight −1.25(0.10) −0.94(1.67)b −0.49(0.16)c 0.001
 Height(cm) 125.45(1.92) 136.39(1.96)b 145.33(2.02)c 0.001
 Height −2.14(0.13) −1.45(0.17)b −1.03(0.18)c 0.001
 BMI 16.53(0.28) 17.52(0.45)b 19.15(0.54)c 0.001
 Boneage(years) 8.09(0.46) 9.86(0.47)b 11.68(4.23)c 0.001
12-15years(n=8)        
 Weight(kg) 39.27(3.39) 45.99(3.53)b 51.55(3.06)c 0.001
 Weight −1.07(0.24) −0.81(0.24)b −0.51(0.24)c 0.001
 Height(cm) 141.20(2.68) 151.44(2.34)b 158.50(1.83)c 0.001
 Height −2.30(0.19) −1.58(0.14)b −0.93(0.12)c 0.001
 BMI 19.46(1.17) 19.86(1.04)b 20.37(1.02)c 0.001
 Boneage(years) 11.13(0.42) 12.63(0.44)b 14.03(0.38)c 0.001
Total(n=19)        
 Weight(kg) 31.66(2.15) 38.28(2.24)b 45.23(2.22)c 0.001
 Weight −1.17(0.11) −0.88(0.14)b −0.50(0.14)c 0.001
 Height(cm) 132.08(2.39) 142.73(2.28)b 150.87(2.05)c 0.001
 Height −2.20(0.11) −1.52(0.11)b −0.99(0.11)c 0.001
 BMI 17.77(0.61) 18.51(0.56)b 19.66(0.53)c 0.001
 Boneage(years) 9.36(0.47) 11.03(0.45)b 12.67(0.39)c 0.001

pa p value of repeated ANOVA; b, significant difference between at base line and after 1yearat p < 0.05; c, significant difference between after 1year and a fter 2 year sat p< 0.05. ∗ rawdata; † z(standard)score.

Table 4.
Comparison of mean of linear and angular measurements between children of short stature and normal stature at baseline by age groups
  Children of short stature Children of normal stature    
Variables 9-11years1 12-15years Total9 -11years1 2-15years Total pa pb
  Mean(SE) Mean(SE) Mean(SE) Mean(SE) Mean(SE) Mean(SE)    
Linear(mm) ACB 64.82(0.87) 66.94(0.63) 65.71(0.61) 67.00(0.59) 68.06(0.73) 67.45(0.46) -
PCB 44.79(0.72) 46.63(0.87) 45.56(0.58) 45.09(0.88) 48.94(1.24) 46.71(0.84) - -
TCB 100.8(1.06) 104.94(1.60) 102.58(1.01) 103.27(0.98) 106.19(1.35) 104.50(0.85) - -
UAFH 51.36(0.67) 54.19(1.27) 52.55(0.72) 52.32(0.64) 56.88(1.10) 54.24(0.78) - -
UPFH 46.73(0.42) 47.50(0.82) 47.05(0.42) 47.45(0.57) 51.19(1.31) 49.03(0.76) -
LAFH 64.45(0.63) 70.13(1.07) 66.84(0.87) 62.91(0.95) 66.60(1.10) 64.46(0.82) - -
ATFH 114.7(1.41) 122.31(2.56) 117.92(1.58) 114.27(1.21) 121.70(1.94) 117.40(1.36) - -
PTFH 70.95(1.42) 66.56(1.88) 69.11(1.22) 70.73(0.77) 79.01(2.22) 74.22(1.39) -
MaxL 45.09(0.95) 45.81(1.60) 45.40(0.85) 45.05(0.64) 49.56(0.97) 46.95(0.75) - -
MandRL 37.95(1.35) 37.56(1.75) 37.79(1.04) 40.45(0.96) 45.56(2.19) 42.61(1.20) -
MandCL 69.91(1.27) 71.31(0.94) 70.50(0.83) 72.73(0.97) 77.25(1.51) 74.63(0.98) -
OMandL 98.23(1.17) 100.81(2.38) 99.32(1.21) 98.23(1.10) 107.13(1.56) 101.97(1.37) - -
Angular(°) SA 127.14(1.37) 128.94(2.40) 127.90(1.26) 124.95(1.06) 122.63(0.84) 123.97(0.74) -
GA 126.86(1.04) 123.81(1.31) 125.58(0.87) 125.41(1.90) 123.75(1.35) 124.71(1.22) - -
MPA 38.05(1.15) 37.50(1.60) 37.82(0.92) 34.05(1.70) 32.13(1.46) 33.24(1.15)
SNA 79.27(0.83) 77.88(1.34) 78.68(0.74) 79.27(0.43) 83.13(1.09) 80.90(0.67) -
SNB 75.18(0.96) 74.13(1.19) 74.74(0.74) 76.18(0.35) 79.69(0.69) 77.66(0.53) -
ANB 4.09(0.44) 3.75(0.67) 3.95(0.37) 3.09(0.47) 3.38(0.71) 3.21(0.39) - -
PPMand 87.64(1.01) 86.19(1.61) 87.03(0.88) 86.73(1.22) 89.19(1.65) 87.76(1.00) - -

pa, value of independent t-test between childrens of shorts tatureand normals tature at baseline; pb, value of interaction effects between a geandgroupusingtwo-way ANOVA.-, not significant; p < 0.05; p< 0.01.SE, Standard error.

Table 5-1.
Comparison of scores for the linear and angular craniofacial variables from baseline to after 2 years among children of short stature
Variables At baseline(n=19) Mean(SE) After 1 year(n=19) Mean(SE) After2years(n=19) pa Mean(SE)
Linear(mm) ACB 65.71(0.61) 67.97(0.62)b 69.63(0.58)c 0.001
  PCB 45.56(0.58) 47.39(0.52)b 48.63(0.54)c 0.001
  TCB 102.58(1.01) 104.05(0.99)b 105.08(1.04)c 0.001
  UAFH 52.55(0.72) 53.89(0.73)b 55.05(0.65)c 0.001
  UPFH 47.05(0.42) 48.50(0.42)b 49.92(0.51)c 0.001
  LAFH 66.84(0.87) 69.39(0.94)b 71.84(0.96)c 0.001
  ATFH 117.92(1.58) 121.00(1.53)b 123.90(1.58)c 0.002
  PTFH 69.11(1.22) 73.84(1.02)b 78.16(0.79)c 0.001
  MaxL 45.40(0.85) 47.63(0.84)b 48.92(0.76)c 0.001
  MandRL 37.79(1.04) 42.00(1.01)b 44.18(0.80)c 0.001
  MandCL 70.50(0.83) 73.05(0.79)b 75.53(0.88)c 0.001
  OMandL 99.32(1.21) 103.29(1.23)b 106.16(1.20)c 0.001
Angular(°) SA 127.90(1.26) 127.08(1.31) 126.37(0.94) 0.572
  GA 125.58(0.87) 125.45(1.22) 126.66(1.14) 0.598
  MPA 37.82(0.92) 36.29(0.95)b 35.47(0.85)c 0.001
  SNA 78.68(0.74) 79.39(0.72) 79.24(0.72) 0.167
  SNB 74.74(0.74) 76.16(0.76)b 76.61(0.71)c 0.001
  ANB 3.95(0.37) 3.24(0.34)b 2.53(0.40)c 0.001
  PPMand 82.97(4.20) 88.24(0.90) 87.45(0.76) 0.390

pa, p value of repeated ANOVA; b, significant difference between at base line and after 1 year at p < 0.05; c, significant difference between after 1 year and after 2 years at p < 0.05. SE, Standard error.

Table 5-2.
Comparison of scores for the linear and angular craniofacial variables from baseline to after 2 years among children of short stature by age groups
Age group Variables At baseline (n=19) Mean(SE) After 1 year(n=19) Mean(SE) After 2 years (n=19) Mean(SE) pa
9-11 years (n=8) Linear(mm)        
  ACB 64.81(0.87) 66.95(0.81)b 68.41(0.76)c 0.001
  PCB 44.79(0.72) 46.96(0.63)b 48.09(0.57)c 0.001
  TCB 100.86(1.06) 102.55(1.07)b 104.09(1.01)c 0.001
  UAFH 51.36(0.67) 52.50(0.66)b 53.82(0.57)c 0.001
  UPFH 46.73(0.42) 47.82(0.41)b 49.41(0.61)c 0.010
  LAFH 64.45(0.63) 66.86(0.72)b 69.68(1.10)c 0.001
  ATFH 114.73(1.41) 116.96(1.19) 121.46(2.07)c 0.042
  PTFH 70.95(1.43) 75.45(1.15)b 78.95(0.94)c 0.001
  MaxL 45.09(0.95) 47.18(0.80)b 48.27(0.72)c 0.001
  MandRL 37.95(1.35) 42.14(1.34)b 44.68(1.01)c 0.001
  MandCL 69.91(1.27) 72.09(1.16)b 74.59(1.32)c 0.001
  OMandL 98.23(1.17) 101.96(0.84)b 105.05(0.98)c 0.001
  Angular(°)        
  SA 127.14(1.37) 126.59(1.35) 126.73(1.43) 0.877
  GA 126.86(1.04) 125.59(1.34) 126.05(1.40) 0.425
  MPA 38.05(1.15) 36.23(1.20)b 35.27(1.00)c 0.001
  SNA 79.27(0.83) 80.23(0.79) 80.05(0.76) 0.400
  SNB 75.18(0.96) 76.77(0.99) 77.05(0.85)c 0.016
  ANB 4.09(0.44) 3.46(0.40)b 3.00(0.33)c 0.014
  PPMand 87.64(1.01) 89.50(0.98) 87.00(1.00) 0.182
12-15years(n=11) Linear(mm)        
  ACB 66.94(0.63) 69.37(0.75)b 71.31(0.43)c 0.001
  PCB 46.62(0.87) 48.00(0.90)b 49.37(1.01)c 0.005
  TCB 104.94(1.60) 106.13(1.66)b 106.44(2.03) 0.071
  UAFH 54.19(1.27) 55.81(1.23)b 56.75(1.10)c 0.002
  UPFH 47.50(0.82) 49.44(0.73)b 50.63(0.84)c 0.004
  LAFH 70.12(1.07) 72.88(1.18)b 74.81(1.05)c 0.007
  ATFH 122.31(2.56) 126.56(1.95)b 127.25(2.01) 0.004
  PTFH 66.56(1.88) 71.63(1.58)b 77.06(1.35)c 0.001
  MaxL 45.81(1.60) 48.25(1.71)b 49.81(1.53)c 0.001
  MandRL 37.56(1.75) 41.81(1.63)b 43.50(1.35)c 0.001
  MandCL 71.31(0.94) 74.38(0.83)b 76.81(0.94)c 0.001
  OMandL 100.81(2.38) 105.13(2.64)b 107.69(2.51)c 0.001
  Angular(°)        
  SA 128.94(2.40) 127.75(2.60) 125.88(1.15) 0.663
  GA 123.81(1.31) 125.25(2.34) 127.50(1.97) 0.188
  MPA 37.50(1.60) 36.38(1.63)b 35.75(1.54)c 0.006
  SNA 77.88(1.34) 78.25(1.28) 78.13(1.30) 0.258
  SNB 74.13(1.19) 75.31(1.17)b 76.00(1.25)c 0.003
  ANB 3.75(0.67) 2.94(0.62) 1.88(0.81)c 0.007
  PPMand 76.56(9.78) 86.50(1.53) 88.06(1.19) 0.427

pa p value of repeated ANOVA; b, significant difference between at base line and after 1 year at p < 0.05; c, significant difference between after 1 year and after 2 year sat p < 0.05.SE, Standard error.

Table 6.
Comparison of scores for the linear and angular craniofacial variables between children of short and normal stature from baseline to after 2 years
  Childrren of short sttature Children of normal stature    
Variables Atbaseline (n=19) Mean(SE) After2years (n=19) Mean(SE) Difference (n=19) Mean(SE) Atbaseline A (n=19) Mean(SE) After2years (n=19) Mean(SE) Difference (n=19) Mean(SE) pa pb
Linear(mm) ACB 65.71(0.61) 69.63(0.58) 3.92(0.34) 67.45(0.46) 68.71(0.45) 1.26(0.14) 0.001 0.001
PCB 45.56(0.58) 48.63(0.54) 3.07(0.38) 46.71(0.84) 48.50(0.81) 1.79(0.26) 0.018 0.020
TCB 102.58(1.01) 105.08(1.04) 2.50(0.66) 104.50(0.85) 107.08(0.83) 2.58(0.30) 0.628 0.611
UAFH 52.55(0.72) 55.05(0.65) 2.50(0.29) 54.24(0.78) 56.47(0.78) 2.24(0.23) 0.811 0.811
UPFH 47.05(0.42) 49.92(0.51) 2.87(0.43) 49.03(0.76) 50.74(0.75) 1.71(0.29) 0.110 0.120
LAFH 66.84(0.87) 71.84(0.96) 5.00(0.64) 64.46(0.82) 67.11(0.84) 2.65(0.24) 0.001 0.001
ATFH 117.92(1.58) 123.90(1.58) 5.97(1.57) 117.40(1.36) 122.14(1.34) 4.74(0.32) 0.358 0.365
PTFH 69.11(1.22) 78.16(0.79) 9.05(0.86) 74.22(1.39) 79.29(1.45) 5.07(0.36) 0.005 0.005
MaxL 45.40(0.85) 48.92(0.76) 3.53(0.38) 46.95(0.75) 49.25(0.72) 2.31(0.41) 0.096 0.096
MandRL L 37.79(1.04) 44.18(0.80) 6.40(0.71) 42.61(1.20) 45.68(1.25) 3.08(0.43) 0.011 0.012
MandCL L 70.50(0.83) 75.53(0.88) 5.03(0.45) 74.63(0.98) 77.89(0.89) 3.26(0.41) 0.078 0.078
OMandL L 99.32(1.21) 106.16(1.20) 6.84(0.87) 101.97(1.37) 106.24(1.11) 4.26(0.59) 0.061 0.061
Angular(°) SA 127.90(1.26) 126.37(0.94) -1.53(1.56) 123.97(0.74) 124.00(0.85) 0.03(0.37) 0.344 0.344
GA 125.58(0.87) 126.66(1.14) 1.08(1.32) 124.71(1.22) 124.45(1.37) -0.26(0.39) 0.269 0.269
MPA 37.82(0.92) 35.47(0.85) -2.34(0.31) 33.24(1.15) 32.32(1.31) -0.92(0.28) 0.004 0.004
SNA 78.68(0.74) 79.24(0.72) 0.56(0.50) 80.90(0.67) 81.44(0.69) 0.54(0.29) 0.542 0.542
SNB 74.74(0.74) 76.61(0.71) 1.87(0.42) 77.66(0.53) 78.72(0.55) 1.06(0.22) 0.465 0.482
ANB 3.95(0.37) 2.53(0.40) -1.42(0.24) 3.21(0.39) 2.72(0.37) -0.49(0.29) 0.047 0.047
PPMand d 82.97(4.20) 87.45(0.76) 4.47(4.28) 87.76(1.00) 88.13(0.81) 0.37(0.47) 0.652 0.609

pa, p value of ANCOVA between children of short and normal stature after 2 years; pb, p value of ANCOVA between children of short and normal stature for difference values. SE, Standard error.

Table 7.
Correlation among the linear and angular craniofacial variables and the z scores of weight and height, BMI, and the bone age in 19 treated short children; difference from baseline to after 2 years
Variables Weight Height BMI Boneage
T0-T1 T1-T2 T0-T2 T0-T1T T1-T2T T0-T2 T0-T1 T1-T2 T0-T2 T0-T1 T1-T2 T0-T2
Linear(mm) ACB -0.28 -0.06 -0.55 -0.27 0.01 -0.34 -0.33 -0.42 -0.41 -0.06 -0.26 -0.12
PCB 0.02 0.07 0.03 -0.15 0.06 -0.41 0.79 -0.08 0.18 -0.15 -0.17 -0.16
TCB 0.20 0.23 0.11 0.11 0.06 0.11 0.07 0.12 -0.03 0.06 0.33 0.35
UAFH -0.18 0.22 -0.12 0.01 0.13 0.20 -0.25 0.21 -0.13 0.14 0.04 0.09
UPFH -0.05 -0.06 0.15 0.14 0.01 0.14 -0.01 -0.14 0.08 -0.05 0.27 0.16
LAFH 0.07 0.15 -0.04 -0.14 0.05 -0.10 0.15 0.13 0.11 -0.19 -0.23 -0.48
ATFH -0.36 0.22 -0.16 -0.35 0.29 0.04 -0.23 0.19 0.02 0.26 -0.16 0.14
PTFH -0.28 -0.28 -0.47 -0.28 0.33 -0.14 -0.24 -0.33 -0.44 0.42 -0.26 0.14
MaxL 0.13 -0.22 0.02 0.13 0.20 0.19 -0.11 -0.23 -0.10 -0.35 -0.31 -0.25
MandRL 0.19 0.32 0.44 0.13 0.10 0.10 0.20 0.36 0.58 0.30 -0.38 0.05
MandCL -0.16 0.02 -0.33 -0.18 0.48 0.16 -0.03 -0.10 -0.32 0.15 -0.12 -0.05
OMandL -0.20 0.09 -0.21 -0.07 0.08 -0.15 -0.03 0.13 -0.05 0.19 -0.47 -0.24
Angular(°) SA 0.15 0.07 -0.25 0.28 -0.22 -0.30 -0.12 0.17 -0.25 0.52 -0.27 0.09
GA -0.26 0.08 -0.15 -0.12 0.05 0.00 -0.16 -0.08 -0.19 -0.48 -0.04 -0.41
MPA -0.12 -0.01 -0.19 0.27 0.46 0.42 -0.31 -0.23 -0.41 -0.29 0.04 -0.05
SNA 0.11 -0.22 0.39 0.19 0.13 0.16 0.07 -0.26 0.37 -0.43 0.17 -0.35
SNB 0.22 -0.20 0.57 0.25 0.17 0.24 0.13 -0.35 0.39 -0.41 0.06 -0.27
ANB -0.22 0.21 -0.12 -0.07 -0.01 -0.08 -0.10 0.28 0.15 -0.21 0.27 -0.10
PPMand -0.10 -0.39 0.02 0.18 0.33 0.41 -0.19 -0.43 -0.13 0.12 0.11 0.18

To, baseline; T1, after 1 year; T2, after 2 years. ∗ p < 0.05.

TOOLS
Similar articles