Since the pandemic (H1N1) 2009 virus has been a seasonal flu which still poses great human health concerns worldwide, vaccination would be considered as the most effective strategy to control the influenza virus spreading. Here, we assessed adjuvant efficacy of modified outer membrane vesicle (mOMV) towards the pandemic H1N1 split antigen.
Materials and Methods
For this study, mice were vaccinated twice with various amount of antigen (0.05, 0.1, and 0.5 µg/dose hemagglutinin [HA]) that were mixed with mOMV, aluminum hydroxide (alum), and MF59, as well as the combined adjuvant comprising the mOMV plus alum.
Results
We found that all the adjuvanted vaccines of A/California/04/09 (CA04, H1N1) containing HA antigen more than 0.1 µg/dose protected effectively from lethal challenge (maCA04, H1N1) virus, compared to the antigen only group. Furthermore, vaccinated mice received as low as 0.05 µg/dose of the split vaccine containing the combined adjuvant (10 µg of mOMV plus alum) showed a full protection against lethal challenge with H1N1 virus. Taken together, these results suggest that mOMV can exert not only the self-adjuvanticity but also a synergy effect for the vaccine efficacy when combined with alum.
Conclusion
Our results indicate that mOMV could be a promising vaccine adjuvant by itself and it could be used as a vaccine platform for development of various vaccine formulations to prepare future influenza pandemic.
Influenza A virusA/California/04/09 (CA04, H1N1)AdjuvantmOMVMinistry of Health and WelfareA103001Korea Research Council of Fundamental Science and TechnologyKorea Research Institute of Bioscience and BiotechnologyKGM3121423Introduction
Influenza viruses have been the cause of morbidity and mortality in both animals and humans [1,2,3]. Since the first emergence in Mexico, the 2009 pandemic A (H1N1) virus has been circulating worldwide as a form of seasonal influenza virus up to date [4,5]. Accordingly, it is reported that influenza A (H1N1)-pdm09 is the most commonly detected virus in most areas of the southern hemisphere. However, influenza virus subtypes vary considerably from country to country [6,7]. Although, ongoing incidence of the H7N9 avian influenza infections occurs in China, still no evidence of any sustained human-to-human transmission has been reported [8].
As a preparedness for future influenza virus pandemic, vaccine development might be considered as the most effective and essential strategy [9,10]. For the development of successful vaccine for influenza, vaccine industry may need development of adjuvants that allows cheaper and more effective vaccine production. During the past decade, a large number of novel adjuvants have been developed and evaluated clinically [11]. There are several adjuvanted influenza vaccines that have been licensed for use in human. Currently, MF59 (Novartis Vaccines and Diagnostics) and aluminum hydroxide (alum) are the two main adjuvants that used largely for production of influenza vaccines [12,13,14]. The adjuvant MF59 has been shown to have a robust safety and efficacy profiles with inducing cross-reactive antibodies against influenza viruses [15], since it was approved for human use more than a decade ago as a type of oil-emulsion adjuvant [14,15,16].
New vaccine adjuvant and vaccine delivery systems have been developed experimentally over the past few years. Among them, we have developed a promising adjuvant candidate called mOMV which is modified outer membrane vesicles (mOMVs). OMVs are considered as an attractive vaccine adjuvant and antigen delivery platform since they were proven to be effective in human meningococcal vaccine and other experimental vaccines in several countries [17,18]. It is known that wild-type OMV (wOMV) has intrinsic inflammatory potential due to their composition with bacterial cell wall constituents such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and peptidoglycan [19]. However, the LPS-modified OMV with strictly penta-acylated lipid A can be produced from Escherichia coli mutant, in order to reduce potential side-effects of the OMV, due to endotoxin activity of its LPS component. Hence, this newly-produced mOMV would be much less-endotoxic and safer than wOMV [19].
Both alum and MF59 adjuvants have been very well known and proven to possess immune stimulatory properties in the adjuvanted vaccines against influenza viruses. It is worth comparing for these widely used adjuvants with the mOMV and studying for its adjuvant efficacy against a highly virulent influenza virus. In this study, we investigated the efficacy of mOMV adjuvant in the split vaccine of A/California/04/09 (CA04, H1N1) by using BALB/c mice via the intramuscular route. Vaccination and challenge experiments in this mouse model study demonstrated that mOMV has a sufficient adjuvant effect on inducing protection from the lethal challenge with influenza A/California/04/09 (maCA04, H1N1) virus. In addition, the H1N1 split vaccine mixed with the combined adjuvant (mOMV plus alum) was more effective in the protection of mice than that of mOMV or alum alone group against challenge with maCA04 (H1N1) virus.
Materials and MethodsVaccine preparation
A/California/04/09 (CA04, H1N1) split vaccine antigen was kindly provided by The Green Cross Reference Lab (Yongin, Korea). Mouse-adapted influenza A/California/04/09 (maCA04, H1N1) virus was generated by site-directed mutagenesis using the GeneTailor kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, USA) according to the manufacturer's instructions. Briefly, the positions at 12, 58, and 88 in PB1-F2 stop codons, which are required for PB1-F2 protein expression, were mutated to serine (S), tryptophan (T), and tryptophan (T), respectively. In addition, the previously known PA (T97I) mutant was also incorporated to enhance virulence in mice [20]. The resulting maCA04 (H1N1) virus was propagated in 11-day-old-embryonic eggs at 37℃ for 72 hours. The allantoic fluid containing the virus was harvested and centrifuged to remove unwanted debris at 3,000 rpm for 10 minutes at 4℃. The harvested virus was dispensed in aliquots and stored at -80℃ until further use. Virus titers were calculated as previously described [20,21].
Vaccination and virus challenge experiments
Four-week-old BALB/c female mice were purchased from Samtako (Osan, Korea). Groups of mice (10 animals per group) were intramuscularly vaccinated with the split vaccine containing 0.05, 0.1, and 0.5 µg/dose of hemagglutinin (HA), respectively, that were mixed with alum (vaccine-alum), MF59 (vaccine-MF59), mOMV (vaccine-mOMV), and the combined adjuvant (vaccine-mOMV plus alum) in 0.2 mL of sterile phosphate-buffered saline (PBS) with two doses at two week intervals, respectively. Two weeks after the last immunization, mice were intranasally (i.n.) challenged with 10 times 50% tissue culture infective doses (TCID50) of the A/California/04/09 (maCA04 [H1N1]) virus. The control group received adjuvant only in 0.25 mL of sterile PBS.
Cell line and hemagglutination inhibition test
Madin-Darby Canine Kidney (MDCK) cells cultured in Eagle's minimal essential medium (EMEM; GIBCO-BRL, Bethesda, MD, USA) with 5% fetal bovine serum (LONZA Inc., Basel, Switzerland), 1% penicillin/streptomycin (Gibco-Invitrogen Inc., Carlsbad, CA, USA), and 1% non-essential amino acids (Gibco-Invitrogen Inc). Cultured MDCK cells were split into 1×105 cells per well in a 96-well plate. Hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assays were done with collected mice sera. Mice sera were collected 2 weeks after each vaccine administration and stored at -80℃ until use. Briefly, the mice sera were treated with receptor destroying enzyme (RDE; Denka Seiken, Tokyo, Japan) to inactivate non-specific inhibitors with a final serum dilution of 1:10. RDE-treated sera were serially diluted 2-fold and 100 TCID50/mL of virus was added to each well. The plates were incubated at room temperature for 30 minutes followed by the addition of 0.5% turkey red blood cells (tRBCs). The plates were incubated at 37℃ for 30 minutes. The HI titer was determined by the reciprocal of the last dilution that contained tRBCs with no agglutination. The limit of detection for the HI assays done was set to ≤20 HI units.
Vaccine experiment and virus titers in lung tissues
The body weight and survival rate was measured daily on days 1 through 15 after challenge virus inoculation. Lung samples from two mice per groups were collected at 1, 3, 5, 7 and 9 days post-infection (dpi) and homogenized with equal volumes (1 mL/g tissue) of PBS-containing 10% antibiotics. Tissue homogenates were clarified by centrifugation at 12,000× rpm for 10 minutes at 4℃ and then supernatants were transferred to new tubes. Samples were 10-fold serially diluted immediately after collection and then inoculated into MDCK cells seeded in 96-well plate plates for virus titration. The plates were incubated at the 37℃ CO2 incubator for 2 hours for viral absorbency. Inoculated supernatant was removed and replaced with EMEM containing 1 µg/mL TPCK-trypsin and then incubated at 37℃ for 48 hours. Virus cytopathic effect was observed daily and the viral titer was determined by the HA test. Hemagglutination assay was performed after 48 hours using tRBCs.
Statistical analysis
Statistical significance of differences in quantitative virus was compared between each vaccinated group and analyzed using the unpaired Student's t test (two-tailed). The value, p<0.05 considered statistically significant was used to determine the p-values of survival calculated by the GraphPad Prism version 5.0 for Window (GraphPad Software, LA Jolla, CA, USA).
ResultsAntibody response induced by mouse vaccination
To investigate the adjuvant efficacy, mice sera from vaccinated groups were analyzed by HI assay to identify IgG antibodies raised against influenza virus. All booster vaccinated groups received the H1N1 split vaccine could elicit the detectable HI titers (≥20 HI unit) against the virus, but no detectable HI titer was observed in the first vaccination and the adjuvant only control groups (Fig. 1). In particular, high HI titer was detected from the 0.5 µg/dose of CA04 (H1N1) split vaccine-MF59 (39 HI), -alum (38 HI), and -mOMV (23 HI) adjuvant groups in the booster vaccine groups, respectively (Fig. 1B, 1C, and 1D), while the split antigen only group showed the lowest HI titers (≤20 HI) against the virus (maCA04 [H1N1]). However, there was no detectable mean HI titer against the heterologous influenza A/Perth/16/2009 (H3N2) and A/PR8/8/34 (H1N1) virus in the vaccinated groups (data not shown).Notably, although it is not statistically significant, the vaccinated group received 0.05 µg/dose of HA in the vaccine-mOMV plus alum could induce a similar level of HI titer comparable to that of the vaccine groups received 0.1 or 0.5 µg/dose of HA (p=0.0695 or p=0.087, respectively). However, when the sera were obtained from the first vaccinated mice with the vaccine-mOMV plus alum, only basal mean HI titer was detected (≤20 HI). Taken together, booster vaccination with the split vaccine-mOMV could efficiently raise HI titer against maCA04 (H1N1) virus.
Survival rate and body weight change after challenge <italic>in vivo</italic>
Two weeks after last vaccination, all vaccinated groups of mice were challenged i.n. with 10 times 50% mouse lethal dose (MLD50) of A/California/04/09 (maCA04, H1N1) virus. To assessthe protective efficacy played by mOMV adjuvant, vaccinated mice received the vaccine-mOMV adjuvant was monitored for the survival rate and body weight change, compared with the cases of vaccine-MF59, -alum, and the vaccine-mOMV plus alum groups (Fig. 2). All mice boosted with 0.1 and 0.5 µg/dose of the adjuvanted vaccine groups could induce high survival rate to 80% and 100% at 15 post day infection (dpi), respectively. However, mock-vaccinated mice, the adjuvant only group, and the mice received 0.05 µg/dose of the antigen alone showed gradual body weight loss and all succumbed to virus challenge within 7 or 8 dpi with severe clinical signs (Figs. 2, 3). On the other hand, it is noteworthy that the mice received 0.05 µg/dose of the vaccine-mOMV plus alum showed attenuation of body weight loss, extended survival, and complete protection, likely those observed in the cases with 0.1 and 0.5 µg/dose of the vaccine during the course of the experiment (Figs. 2E, 3E). In contrast, a significantly reduced mortality was exhibited in the vaccinated mice received 0.05 µg/dose of the vaccine containing 10 µg of mOMV (40%), alum (50%), and MF59 (60%). The antigen only group also showed a gradual body weight loss and succumbed at 7 dpi in the 0.05 µg/dose group. The vaccinated mice received 0.1 and 0.5 µg/dose of HA survived only 20% and 30% at 15 dpi, respectively. Taken together, these results suggest that the vaccine-mOMV has a capacity similar or same protective efficacy to the vaccine-alum or -MF59. Furthermore, the vaccine-mOMV plus alum at 0.05 µg/dose of HA could induce a better protection than the single mOMV adjuvanted vaccine against lethal challenge with maCA04 (H1N1) virus.
Viral load in the lung of vaccinated mice
To determine the viral load in the lung of vaccinated mice, virus titers of each group were monitored (Table 1). Viral titers in the mice lung (collected at 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10 dpi) showed that the vaccine-mOMV group efficiently inhibited viral replication at 4 and 6 dpi upon lethal challenge with maCA04 (H1N1) virus, compared to the mock (adjuvant and antigen only) groups (Table 1). Viral titers in the vaccine-mOMV group at 0.5 µg/dose showed similar levels of virus titer with those groups received the vaccine-alum and -MF59 adjuvants. As expected, adjuvant alone groups exhibited a clear increase of virus replication in the lungs ranging from 2.50 to 3.75 TCID50 titration (log10TCID50/mL) from 2 to 6 dpi. All the adjuvanted vaccine groups at 0.1 µg/dose of HA appeared to inhibit virus replication in the mice lung, compared to the antigen only group. However, viral inhibition was not detected at the 0.05 µg/dose of the vaccine-MF59 and similar or gradual viral inhibition was detected at the 0.05 µg/dose of the vaccine-mOMV, -alum after 6 and 8 dpi, respectively. Although, it is not statically significant, it is noteworthy that the vaccine-mOMV plus alum at 0.05 µg/dose of HA could clearly induce the most efficient inhibition of lung viral titers starting at 6 dpi with 1.25 TCID50. We demonstrated that the H1N1 vaccine-mOMV could elicit the strong immune response enough to clear the viral load in the infected lung of the vaccinated mice. Altogether, these results clearly demonstrated that mOMV can exert the adjuvant effect by itself and showed synergistic effects when it mixed with alum. Consequently, mOMV could be used as a next-generation vaccine adjuvant for production of a cheaper and more effective vaccines developed as a mean of preparedness to influenza virus pandemic in the future.
Discussion
Now a days, MF59 is the most commonly used adjuvant for influenza virus vaccines. The squalene oil-in-water emulsion (MF59) provides immunogenicity and protection against influenza virus in humans. However, despite the effectiveness, intricate process in manufacturing and higher production cost would be still a matter of concern for MF59 to be accepted as next generation vaccine adjuvant.
The mOMV we developed previously is a novel, nano-size particle, generated from the ΔmsbB/ΔpagP mutant of non-pathogenic E. coli W3110 and thus very cost effective, compared with other adjuvants. In this study, we compared the adjuvant efficacy of the mOMV with that of well-known adjuvants such as MF59 and alum by using H1N1-pdm09 split vaccine. We demonstrated that the vaccine-mOMV could induce a protective immunity when evaluated by survival rate and body weight loss due to the adjuvant efficacy for inducing high HI titers against maCA04 (H1N1) virus, compared to the antigen only or the adjuvant only groups.
A number of studies with a view to assessing adjuvant efficacy have been conducted with accumulation of safety profiles [22,23]. MF59 adjuvant was effective in inducing immunogenicity of the vaccine approximately 3 times higher than the case of alum-adjuvanted vaccine [24], in agreement with the previous study in hepatitis B virus vaccines [25]. Also, the results obtained from this study using the booster vaccinated mice received the adjuvanted vaccines could induce high mean HI titer and protect efficiently from lethal challenge with maCA04 (H1N1) virus, although the first inoculated mice groups could not elaborate high HI titers. The mOMV-adjuvanted vaccine elaborated viral clearance against maCA04 (H1N1) in the mice lung. This result clearly demonstrated that mOMV adjuvant plays an important role in the efficacy of influenza vaccine by inducing high mean HI titer and protecting the lung from viral replication (Table 1, Fig. 1).
Previous studies indicated that inactivated 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine at varying dosages of HA with extemporaneously mixed AS03 adjuvant system was improved the immune response at high dosage adjuvant vaccine on adult groups [26]. In agreement with these results, we demonstrated that 0.05 µg/dose of HA containing mixed with mOMV and alumadjuvant attenuated body weight loss and increased survival rate after challenge maCA04 (H1N1) virus infection than those of individual adjuvant groups. Those results might be due to the possibility that the combined adjuvant (mOMV plus alum) have played synergistically in the vaccine. The mOMV has adjuvant activity on T cell priming in a Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4)-dependent manner [19,27]. Furthermore, mOMV can stimulate DCs enough to up-regulate expression of co-stimulatory and antigen-presenting molecules and to produce proinflammatory cytokines in a TLR-dependent fashion [19].
In summary, our results suggest that mOMV can exert not only the self-adjuvanticity but also a synergy effect for influenza vaccine efficacy when combined with alum. Thus, mOMV could be used as a vaccine platform for development of various formulations to prepare future influenza pandemic.
No potential conflict of interest relevant to this article was reported.
This work was supported partly by a grant from the Korea Healthcare Technology R&D Project (grant No.: A103001) by the Ministry of Health and Welfare, and by a National Agenda Project granted from the Korea Research Council of Fundamental Science and Technology, and by the KRIBB Initiative Program (KGM3121423).
AtmarRLKeitelWAAdjuvants for pandemic influenza vaccinesCurr Top Microbiol Immunol2009333323344Novel Swine-Origin Influenza A (H1N1) Virus InvestigationDawoodFSJainSEmergence of a novel swine-origin influenza A (H1N1) virus in humansN Engl J Med200936026052615JainSKamimotoLBramleyAMHospitalized patients with 2009 H1N1 influenza in the United States, April-June 2009N Engl J Med200936119351944OrstedIMolvadgaardMNielsenHLNielsenHThe first, second and third wave of pandemic influenza A (H1N1)pdm09 in North Denmark Region 2009-2011: a population-based study of hospitalizationsInfluenza Other Respir Viruses20137776782TrauerJMBandaranayakeDBooyRSeroepidemiologic effects of influenza A(H1N1)pdm09 in Australia, New Zealand, and SingaporeEmerg Infect Dis20131992101KlimovAIGartenRRussellCWHO recommendations for the viruses to be used in the 2012 Southern Hemisphere Influenza Vaccine: epidemiology, antigenic and genetic characteristics of influenza A (H1N1) pdm09, A (H3N2) and B influenza viruses collected from February to September 2011Vaccine20123064616471MajanjaJNjorogeRNAchillaRImpact of influenza A (H1N1)pdm09 virus on circulation dynamics of seasonal influenza strains in KenyaAm J Trop Med Hyg201388940945TangRBChenHLAn overview of the recent outbreaks of the avian-origin influenza A (H7N9) virus in the humanJ Chin Med Assoc201376245248GirardMPKatzJPervikovYPalkonyayLKienyMPReport of the 6th meeting on the evaluation of pandemic influenza vaccines in clinical trials World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 17-18 February 2010Vaccine20102868116820GirardMPTamJSAssossouOMKienyMPThe 2009 A (H1N1) influenza virus pandemic: a reviewVaccine20102848954902ScheifeleDWWardBJDionneMCompatibility of ASO3-adjuvanted H1N1pdm09 and seasonal trivalent influenza vaccines in adults: results of a randomized, controlled trialVaccine20123047284732BanzhoffAHaertelSPrausMPassive surveillance of adverse events of an MF59-adjuvanted H1N1v vaccine during the pandemic mass vaccinationsHum Vaccin20117539548CristianiCTuccoriMPepePSafety of MF-59 adjuvanted vaccine for pandemic influenza: results of the vaccination campaign in an Italian health districtVaccine20112934433448O'HaganDTOttGSDe GregorioESeubertAThe mechanism of action of MF59: an innately attractive adjuvant formulationVaccine20123043414348O'HaganDTRappuoliRDe GregorioETsaiTDel GiudiceGMF59 adjuvant: the best insurance against influenza strain diversityExpert Rev Vaccines201110447462TsaiTFMF59 adjuvanted seasonal and pandemic influenza vaccinesYakugaku Zasshi201113117331741NorheimGTunheimGNaessLMKristiansenPACaugantDARosenqvistEAn outer membrane vesicle vaccine for prevention of serogroup A and W-135 meningococcal disease in the African meningitis beltScand J Immunol20127699107CollinsBSGram-negative outer membrane vesicles in vaccine developmentDiscov Med201112715LeeDHKimSHKangWAdjuvant effect of bacterial outer membrane vesicles with penta-acylated lipopolysaccharide on antigen-specific T cell primingVaccine20112982938301SongMSPascuaPNLeeJHThe polymerase acidic protein gene of influenza a virus contributes to pathogenicity in a mouse modelJ Virol2009831232512335SongMSPascuaPNLeeJHVirulence and genetic compatibility of polymerase reassortant viruses derived from the pandemic (H1N1) 2009 influenza virus and circulating influenza A virusesJ Virol20118562756286GordonDLSajkovDWoodmanRJRandomized clinical trial of immunogenicity and safety of a recombinant H1N1/2009 pandemic influenza vaccine containing Advax polysaccharide adjuvantVaccine20123054075416PeetersMRegnerSVamanTDevasterJMRomboLSafety and immunogenicity of an AS03-adjuvanted A(H1N1)pmd09 vaccine administered simultaneously or sequentially with a seasonal trivalent vaccine in adults 61 years or older: data from two multicentre randomised trialsVaccine20123064836491ClarkTWPareekMHoschlerKTrial of 2009 influenza A (H1N1) monovalent MF59-adjuvanted vaccineN Engl J Med200936124242435HeinemanTCClements-MannMLPolandGAA randomized, controlled study in adults of the immunogenicity of a novel hepatitis B vaccine containing MF59 adjuvantVaccine19991727692778JacksonLAChenWHStapletonJTImmunogenicity and safety of varying dosages of a monovalent 2009 H1N1 influenza vaccine given with and without AS03 adjuvant system in healthy adults and older personsJ Infect Dis2012206811820LeeBJLeeSHSongMSAdjuvant efficacy of mOMV against avian influenza virus infection in miceJ Microbiol201351682688
Hemagglutination inhibition (HI) titers raised in the mice received the adjuvanted H1N1 split vaccine. Groups of 4-week-old mice were vaccinated twice at a two-week interval with H1N1pdm virus. Sera were collected from peri-orbital sinus after 2 weeks post-vaccination of the last vaccine, and mean HI titers against A/California/04/09 (CA04, H1N1) virus was determined and expressed as the reciprocal of the highest dilution of serum. (A) The antigen only groups at different doses (0.05, 0.1, and 0.5 µg/dose). (B) The modified outer membrane vesicle (mOMV)-adjuvanted groups. (C) The aluminum hydroxide (alum)-adjuvanted groups. (D) The MF59-adjuvanted groups. (E) The mOMV+alum combined adjuvanted groups. The limit of detection for the HI assays done was set to ≤20 HI unites.
Body weight change after virus challenge. Body weight was monitored in the vaccinated mice after challenge with A/California/04/09 (maCA04, H1N1) virus for 15 days post-infection. (A) H1N1pdm antigen only groups at different doses (0.05, 0.1, and 0.5 µg/dose). (B) The modified outer membrane vesicle (mOMV)-adjuvanted groups. (C) The aluminum hydroxide (alum)-adjuvanted groups. (D) The MF59-adjuvanted groups. (E) The mOMV+alum combined adjuvanted groups. The monitoring of mice lost their body weight more than 20% was terminated as death. Error bar represents average weight of each group at the indicated day. HI, hemagglutination inhibition.
Survival rate of the vaccinated mice after the virus challenge. Survival rate of the booster-vaccinated mice was monitored every day during 15 days post-infection. (A) H1N1 pdm antigen only groups at different doses (0.05, 0.1, and 0.5 µg/dose). (B) The modified outer membrane vesicle (mOMV)-adjuvanted groups. (C) The aluminum hydroxide (alum)-adjuvanted groups. (D) The MF59-adjuvanted groups. (E) The mOMV+alum combined adjuvanted groups.The immunized mice were challenged with lethal dose of A/California/04/09 (maCA04, H1N1) virus. Each point represents the mean body weight of 10 mice per group (n=10).
Vaccine-induced TCID50 titers and inhibition of virus replication in mice lung